ADA website demand letter: what to do in the first week
If you got an ADA website demand letter, here is what to do: do not ignore it, do not pay or reply right away, and call a lawyer who knows website accessibility cases before you do anything else. Then record the state of your site, and fix the real errors in your code. This guide is for owners of small business sites who just opened one of these letters. We are not lawyers and this is not legal advice; a lawyer who has read your actual letter has to guide the legal side.
What is an ADA website demand letter?
It is a letter or email from a person or a law firm saying your website is hard or impossible for people with disabilities to use, and asking you to fix it, pay, or both. It is a request, not a court order. BOIA, an accessibility company, describes demand letters as the first step toward costly litigation that does not always end in a lawsuit. Some letters name exact errors. Some are near-identical copies sent to many businesses, so read yours closely.
The ADA does not name a technical standard for websites. In practice, letters and courts point to WCAG, usually version 2.1 level AA. See our ADA website compliance requirements guide for what that means.
ADA website demand letter: what to do on day one
- Breathe, and do not delete anything. Keep the letter, the envelope or email headers, and any attachments.
- Do not reply to the sender yet. BOIA advises not contacting the other side unless your attorney says to. A casual reply can be read as an admission.
- Do not pay or sign anything. NFIB notes that many small business owners want to settle fast, and experts urge caution before doing so.
- Note the deadline in the letter. Some letters set one. Tell your lawyer the same day, so the clock is not a surprise.
- Tell your insurer if your policy may apply. Whether it does is a question for the policy and your lawyer.
Should I hire a lawyer for a website demand letter?
Multiple guides put this first: talk to counsel before any other step. Website accessibility is a narrow area, so ask for a lawyer who has handled these cases, not any lawyer. Our guide to hiring an ADA website compliance attorney says what to bring and what to ask, including fees and whether they work with a technical expert.
Do you need one for every letter? That is for your lawyer to say after reading it. Paying a short consult to learn how serious yours is can cost much less than a wrong guess.
What to gather for your lawyer
- The letter and anything that came with it, with the date you got it.
- Your website's address, the platform it runs on, and who built and maintains it.
- A list of every page the letter names, and any errors it lists.
- Your insurance policy numbers.
- Whether you ever had an accessibility statement, an audit or a widget installed, and the dates.
- Any past complaints from customers about using the site.
Check what is true on your site, in writing
After you speak with counsel, find out what the site really looks like. Record it before you change anything, as one guide notes: a dated snapshot of the state before fixes is often overlooked, and a lawyer may want it.
- Take dated screenshots of the pages named, and save the page source if you can.
- Run a free scanner on those pages and save the report. Our free checker guide shows three.
- Test by hand. Press Tab from the top of each page. Can you reach the menu, the main action and the form? A scanner finds only part of the problems, so this step matters.
- Make a plain list of each error, where it is, and who can fix it: you, your developer, or a plugin or platform vendor.
Our audit report example shows what a clear written list looks like.
Is the letter real, and can I ignore it?
Do not ignore it. Even a poorly made letter can lead to a suit if it is a real firm. But do check it: some firms send the same letter to many small businesses, and fake letters exist. Check the firm's name, a bar number and a phone number you find yourself, not the one in the letter. Ask your lawyer to confirm. Do not click links or open attachments from a sender you cannot verify.
What not to do while the letter is open
- Do not take the site down in a panic or rewrite it in a weekend. Rushed edits can break checkout and erase evidence.
- Do not paste in a widget and call it done. Overlay widgets have not stopped suits; sites using them have been named in some. See the overlay lawsuit guide and why experts say overlays are bad.
- Do not post an accessibility statement that promises more than you can show. Say what you tested and how to reach a person. See whether a statement is a legal requirement.
- Do not discuss it in public on social media or review sites.
How to fix the errors once counsel is on board
The work usually runs in this order, and your lawyer may set the pace:
- Fix what blocks a task first: checkout, the contact form, the phone number, the menu and booking.
- Then the common errors: missing alt text, unnamed buttons and links, low contrast, form labels, heading order.
- Retest after each batch with a scanner and by keyboard, and save the results with dates.
- Keep the records in one folder for your lawyer.
On cost: a one-time fix of the common errors on a small site is usually $1,500 to $3,500 at $100 to $200 an hour (see remediation cost). A monthly widget adds up to about $2,000 to $4,000 over five years and leaves your files unchanged. For help choosing a fixer, read accessibility remediation services.
Questions to ask your lawyer in the first call
- Is this letter from a firm you know, and is it one of many identical letters?
- What is the deadline, and what happens if I miss it?
- Should I reply, or will you?
- What should I change on the site now, and what should I leave alone until you say?
- How do you bill, and what is the likely range for each stage?
- Do you work with a technical expert who can test the site and write a report?
Write the answers down. A short call with notes is worth more than a long call you cannot remember.
What the letter may ask you to do
Letters vary. Many ask for a promise to fix the named errors by a date, a payment, a signed agreement, or all three. Each of those is a legal choice, so none should be agreed to before your lawyer has read the letter. The fix itself is a technical task you can start planning in parallel: a list of errors, an owner for each, and a date.
A first-week plan
| Day | Do |
|---|---|
| 1 | Save the letter, note any deadline, do not reply or pay, call a lawyer who handles website cases |
| 2 | Send your lawyer the gathered facts; ask what to say to the sender, if anything |
| 3 | Take dated screenshots and a scanner report of the named pages |
| 4 | Tab through the site by hand; make the error list |
| 5 | Choose who fixes: you, your developer or a specialist; get a written quote |
| 6–7 | Start with the pages and tasks the letter names; retest and save results |
Two small business examples
A salon with a booking page from another company. The letter names the booking form. The owner cannot change that code, so the lawyer and the owner write to the booking company about its accessibility report and its fix dates, and keep a phone and email option visible in the meantime. The owner fixes their own pages first.
A gift shop on a hosted platform. The letter lists missing image descriptions and an unlabeled search box. The owner takes dated screenshots, adds descriptions to the product photos, labels the search box, and retests, with the lawyer deciding what to send back.
Frequently asked questions
What should I do if I get an ADA website demand letter?
Do not ignore it, pay or sign yet. Call a lawyer who handles website accessibility cases, keep the letter, and record the state of your site before you change it.
Should I respond to the demand letter myself?
Guides advise not contacting the sender unless your attorney says to, since a casual reply can be used against you.
Can I just install an accessibility overlay?
It is not a safe answer. Sites with overlays have been named in suits, and the widget does not change your code.
How long do I have to respond?
It depends on the letter. Some set a deadline; others do not. BOIA's guide gives no fixed time. Tell your lawyer the date on day one.
How much does it cost to fix a website after a letter?
A small business fix is usually $1,500 to $3,500 once. Legal costs are separate and depend on your lawyer and your case.
Sources
- BOIA, "Steps to Take After Receiving an ADA Website Demand Letter", boia.org (read 2026-11-21; published 2022).
- NFIB, "Responding to ADA Lawsuits", nfib.com.
- accessible.org, "After You Receive an ADA Website Demand Letter, Next Steps".
- accessibilitychecker.org, "7 Immediate Steps to Take When You Get a Website Accessibility Demand Letter".
- W3C, Web Content Accessibility Guidelines 2.1.