HACCP vs GMP: what is the difference, and which does a restaurant need?
HACCP and GMP are not rivals. GMP (good manufacturing practice) is the set of basic cleanliness and handling rules a food business follows every day, such as clean hands, clean equipment and pest control. HACCP is a plan that finds the few steps where a hazard could reach the customer and puts a limit and a record on each one. GMP is the floor; HACCP sits on top of it.
This guide is for restaurant owners and managers who hear both words, often from an inspector or a buyer, and want to know which one applies to them and what to write down. It compares the two, shows how they fit together in a restaurant kitchen, and says where each is a rule and where it is a good habit. To see a plan built from your own menu, find your restaurant and see your plan.
Want the HACCP part written for your menu? See your plan, built from your menu. No card.
HACCP vs GMP: the short difference
| GMP | HACCP | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Basic hygiene and handling rules for the whole operation | A written plan for the specific steps where a hazard must be controlled |
| Question it answers | Is the place clean and run in a sanitary way? | What could make a customer sick here, and what stops it? |
| Scope | Everything: people, building, equipment, pests, water, storage | A few critical points, such as cooking, cooling, holding |
| Records | Cleaning, pest, training and maintenance records | Temperatures, times, corrective actions, verification |
| Example | Staff wash hands; sinks are stocked; pests are controlled | Chicken cooked to 165°F and logged; cooling done in 6 hours |
A common way to say it in food safety courses: GMPs and other support programs are the "prerequisite programs" that HACCP stands on. HACCP alone is not a complete food safety system; it is supported by prerequisite programs [1][2]. If the floor is dirty, no plan at the cooking step will save you.
What are GMPs?
GMP stands for good manufacturing practice, also written cGMP with a "c" for current. In the United States, the FDA wrote them into the rules for food made in factories: 21 CFR Part 117, which replaced the older Part 110 [1]. They cover:
- People: clean clothes, hair restraints, hand washing, not working sick.
- Buildings and grounds: floors, walls, lighting, ventilation, pest control.
- Equipment and tools: cleanable, in good repair, sanitized.
- Production and storage: food kept off the floor, protected from cross-contact, held at the right temperature.
A restaurant is not a factory, so those rules are not written for you. The same ideas appear in the FDA Food Code, the model rule your state and county use to inspect restaurants [3]. In practice, when a restaurant person says "GMPs" they mean the hygiene routine: hand washing, cleaning, pests, training. These are the same items on your cleaning log, your pest control log and your training records.
What is HACCP?
HACCP stands for Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Points. You list your dishes, find where a hazard (germs, chemicals, a bone or glass) could get in or grow, and mark the steps that must be controlled. For each such step you write a limit, how you will check it, what you do if it fails, and the record you keep. Those are the HACCP principles. We walk through them with restaurant examples in critical control point examples and in the HACCP plan for a restaurant.
A restaurant plan is built from the hot spots in the menu: cooking, hot holding, cold holding, cooling, reheating and receiving. Each has a temperature or a time, so each has a log.
How GMP and HACCP fit together in a kitchen
Take a chicken dinner:
- Receiving. GMP says the delivery dock is clean and the cooler is not overloaded. HACCP says chicken arrives at 41°F or below and you log it (receiving log).
- Storage. GMP says raw chicken goes on the bottom shelf, labeled. HACCP says the cooler stays at 41°F or below, checked and logged (refrigerator log).
- Prep. GMP says clean boards and washed hands. HACCP does not log this step.
- Cooking. HACCP: cook to 165°F, probe the thickest part, record it [3].
- Holding. HACCP: hot at 135°F or above (hot holding).
- Cooling leftovers. HACCP: 135°F to 70°F in 2 hours, then to 41°F in 4 more (cooling log).
- Cleaning and pests. GMP: sanitizer at the right strength, pests controlled (sanitizer log).
Both give you records, but they answer different questions. If you were asked in an inspection "do you wash and sanitize?" that is GMP. If asked "how do you know this was cooked enough?" that is HACCP.
Which does a restaurant need?
Both ideas apply; what is required on paper depends on where you are and what you make.
- Most restaurants. State and county rules based on the Food Code require the hygiene basics, and temperature and time rules. A full written HACCP plan is not required for every restaurant [3]. The Food Code asks for one in certain cases, such as some specialized processes (for example, smoking food as a way to preserve it, curing, some vacuum packing, or serving raw oysters in some places). See do restaurants need a HACCP plan.
- Specialty processing. Sous vide, curing, fermenting, and reduced oxygen packaging often need a plan on file. See sous vide, vacuum sealing and smoked and cured meats. Ask your health department first.
- Selling to others. A buyer, a school, a hotel or a caterer may ask for HACCP papers as a condition. Then the answer is whatever the buyer says. See catering and school food service.
- Meat, seafood and juice makers. Federal HACCP rules cover these industries; the newer preventive controls rules cover most other processed food [2]. A restaurant that packs and sells food under its own label may cross into those rules. Ask your regulator.
Even where HACCP is not required, a short plan is the best way to explain your kitchen to an inspector and to new staff. We also compare it with a general food safety plan in HACCP vs a food safety plan and with a training certificate in ServSafe vs HACCP.
HACCP, GMP and the other words you will hear
- Prerequisite programs (PRPs). The support programs HACCP relies on. GMP is one; others are supplier approval, recall steps and sanitation procedures [2].
- SSOP. Sanitation standard operating procedures: written steps for cleaning. Part of the prerequisites.
- SOP. Any written step-by-step: how to open the kitchen, how to calibrate a thermometer.
- HARPC and preventive controls. The factory rule's name for a hazard plan; these terms apply to food manufacturers, not usually to a restaurant [2].
- Food safety plan. A plain term for your written plan, which may contain HACCP steps plus your hygiene rules.
- Food safety management system. The whole set: plan, programs, records, training, reviews. See food safety management systems.
A simple way to cover both
- Write down your hygiene routine. One page: hand washing, sick staff, cleaning schedule, pest control, who is in charge.
- Write a one-page hazard plan. List the dishes that need a temperature or a time. A table with the dish, step, limit, check, fix and record is enough to start; see the plan format.
- Pick the logs that match. Cold units, hot holding, cooling, reheating, receiving, and the cleaning sheet.
- Train staff on both. Keep a signed list.
- Review monthly. Read the logs, mark the gaps and fix them. See verification.
Mistakes
- Treating HACCP as a binder that never opens.
- Writing a plan for cooking when the floor and the hands are dirty.
- Copying a factory plan into a restaurant: the steps and words will not fit.
- Logging things that have no limit, like "kitchen clean". Use the cleaning sheet for that.
Questions
Is GMP part of HACCP?
Not exactly. GMP and similar programs come first and support HACCP. HACCP then adds a plan for the specific critical steps [1][2].
Which comes first, GMP or HACCP?
GMP. A hazard plan works only when the basics are in place.
Does a restaurant need a HACCP plan?
Not every restaurant. It is required in some cases, such as certain special processes, and it is a smart tool otherwise. Ask your health department. See do restaurants need a HACCP plan.
What does cGMP stand for?
Current good manufacturing practice. The "c" means the practice must keep up with current standards [1].
Is GMP a law?
For factories that make food in the US, yes, as 21 CFR Part 117 [1]. For a restaurant, the matching rules are your local food code.
Can I pass an inspection with GMP only?
Inspections look at both hygiene and temperature control. If food is held hot or cold, an inspector will check the temperatures.
To get the hazard plan and logs built from your own menu, see your plan.
Sources
- University of Florida IFAS Extension, "Food Safety Systems: Prerequisite Programs and Validation" (FS138): GMPs, 21 CFR Part 117 replacing Part 110. https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FS138
- Michigan State University Extension, "Food Safety Systems: Prerequisite Programs and Validation". https://www.canr.msu.edu/resources/food-safety-systems-prerequisite-programs-validation
- FDA Food Code 2022: cooking, holding, cooling, and when a HACCP plan is required for specialized processes. https://www.fda.gov/food/retail-food-protection/fda-food-code