Find my businessStart

Infrared vs probe thermometer for a restaurant: which one goes on the log

A probe thermometer reads the inside of the food. An infrared thermometer reads only the surface it points at. So the probe is the one whose number goes on a food temperature log, and the infrared gun is a quick scanner for boxes, shelves and cooler walls. You need a probe either way; the infrared gun is optional.

This guide is for restaurant owners and managers who have been handed an infrared "temp gun" and are wondering if it counts, or who are deciding what to buy. It covers what each tool measures, which kitchen checks each one may be used for, a simple test that shows the surface error, and a short buying list. If you would rather have the plan and the logs built from your menu, see your plan.

Which readings go on the log? See the plan and logs built from your menu. No card.

What each thermometer measures

A probe (also called an instant-read or stem thermometer) has a metal tip that you push into the food. The sensor sits in or near the tip, so it reports the temperature of the spot where the tip sits. Push it into the thickest part of a chicken breast and you get the temperature of the thickest part.

An infrared thermometer has no probe. You point it, squeeze the trigger, and it reads the heat given off by the surface in front of the lens. It does not see through the skin of a roast, the lid of a pan, or the film on a pot of soup. Makers' spec sheets describe an infrared reading as a surface reading, and food safety guidance from the FDA and USDA is built around probes placed in the food [1][2].

That one difference drives everything else in this guide. The food safety limits in your plan are limits on the temperature of the food itself: 41°F or colder when held cold, 135°F or hotter when held hot, 165°F inside chicken. A surface can be several degrees away from the middle. A hot pan of soup has a cooler skin where steam leaves it. A tray of chicken taken out of a walk-in has a warm surface within a minute. In both cases the gun shows you the skin, and the log asks about the middle.

Infrared vs probe: side by side

Probe (digital, instant-read)Infrared gun
ReadsInside the food, at the tipSurface only
SpeedA few secondsAbout a second
Touches foodYes, so it must be washed and sanitized between foodsNo
Good forCooking, hot and cold holding, cooling, reheating, receivingScanning many boxes, shelves, cooler walls, a dish machine rack, a pizza oven deck
Poor atScanning twenty boxes in a hurryShiny steel, steam, foil, liquids, anything inside a container
Can you calibrate it?Many can; all can be tested in ice waterUsually cannot be tested the same way, since it does not go in water
Counts on a log?YesOnly for surface or "scan" lines, never for a food limit
Typical costRead the current listing; a decent one is not expensiveSimilar range; more for a model with a laser and a spot size you can read

Prices change, so this table gives no figures. Check the listing on the day you buy, and compare the stated accuracy, not the brand.

Where infrared can mislead you

The gun is not a bad tool. It gives wrong answers in a few predictable cases, and a cook who does not know them will trust a wrong number.

A five-minute test you can run today

You do not need to take anyone's word for this. Do it with the thermometers you own.

  1. Heat a cup of water to about 140°F or fill a small pan of cooked food, such as rice, and let it sit uncovered for ten minutes.
  2. Take a probe reading in the middle. Write it down.
  3. Point the infrared gun at the top of the food, from a few inches away. Write it down.
  4. Point it at the pan's steel side. Write it down.
  5. Do the same with a container of cold food from the walk-in after it has been on the counter for two minutes.

Most kitchens find the three readings differ by several degrees, and the gap is largest on the steel and on the cold food that has begun to warm at the edge. Keep the page. When someone asks "why can't we log the gun?", it is a better answer than a rule.

Which check, which tool

Use this table to set the rule on your own line. Limits are those in the FDA Food Code; your health department may adopt a different version, so check yours [3].

CheckLimitProbeInfrared
Receiving cold food41°F or below (eggs: air at 45°F or below)Yes: log this numberScreen boxes first; probe any that look warm
Receiving frozen foodFrozen solid, no signs of thawingProbe if in doubtScreen only
Cooking165°F poultry, 155°F ground meat, 145°F whole cutsYesNo
Hot holding135°F or aboveYesNo
Cold holding, prep rail41°F or belowYesNo (it reads the pan and the cold air)
Cooling135 to 70°F in 2 hours, then 70 to 41°F in 4 moreYes, at the middle of the deepest panNo
Reheating165°F within 2 hours for hot holdingYesNo
Walk-in and reach-in air41°F or belowCup of water, read with a probeWall and shelf scan only; use a unit thermometer for the log
Dish machine surfacePer the label of the machineMaker's methodNot a substitute for the maker's method
Oven, griddle, fryer oilPer recipeProbe in the oil or foodFine for a quick look at a griddle surface

The rule that comes out of the table is short: the number that proves food is safe comes from a probe in the food. The gun can decide where to probe first.

How a gun saves time without hurting the log

A manager checking a delivery of twenty cases does not want to open twenty cases. A good routine:

  1. Scan the outside of each case with the gun. Any case that reads above about 45°F gets set aside.
  2. Take a probe reading from the set-aside cases first. If one is at 41°F or below, it can go in the walk-in. If it is above 41°F, follow your receiving rule: reject, or log a corrective action.
  3. Probe one or two cases of each kind of food, such as chicken, fish and dairy, whatever the scan said. Write those probe numbers on the receiving log.

The gun made the check faster, and the log still holds the probe's numbers. The same pattern works for a walk-in: scan the shelves with the gun to find a warm spot near the door, then put a probe in a cup of water at that spot and log that.

What to write on the log

If your team uses both tools, add a column to the log for the tool, or put "P" or "IR" beside the number. Inspectors do not ask for it, but it keeps a surface number from being counted as a food number. Here is a filled example of the lines for one morning:

TimeItemToolReadingLimitOK?Action and initials
7:40Dairy delivery, case 1IR (scan)38°FscreenYesMR
7:41Dairy delivery, milkP39°F41°FYesMR
7:44Chicken case 2IR (scan)47°FscreenProbe itMR
7:45Chicken case 2, thighP43°F41°FNoRejected, driver signed the slip, MR

Ask the whole team to treat "Probe it" as a normal entry, so nobody feels the gun's number has to be hidden. For the other log layouts, see examples of HACCP logs and the restaurant temperature log sheet.

Does an inspector accept an infrared thermometer?

Inspectors use both. They often carry a probe for food and may use an infrared device for walls and equipment. What they check is the food temperature, so a log that records infrared surface numbers as food temperatures is a weak record. The Food Code asks for a food temperature measuring device that you can use to measure the temperature of food, and a probe that is small enough for thin food [3]. Ask your health department if it has a written preference, and keep that email or note in the binder.

What to buy

If you buy only one, buy a digital probe. If you add a second tool, add another probe before you add a gun. A short list for a small restaurant:

  1. Two digital probes with a stated accuracy of about ±2°F or better, a thin tip, and a display you can read with gloves on. One stays on the line; one lives at receiving. The longer buying guide is best restaurant thermometer for food safety.
  2. A thermometer in every cold unit. Air thermometers are not food thermometers, so test them against a cup of water.
  3. A spare probe, checked and put away.
  4. Optional: an infrared gun, with a spot size listed on the spec sheet, for a busy receiving dock or a large walk-in.
  5. Alcohol wipes or sanitizer for probes, kept at each station, because a probe that goes from raw chicken to a salad without a wipe is a contamination risk.

Wireless probes and logging alarms are a separate option, covered in Bluetooth thermometers for restaurants and digital temperature data loggers.

Checking each tool is still right

A probe can be tested in a cup of crushed ice and water: it should read 32°F, give or take 2°F [2]. See the thermometer calibration log for the steps and a filled sheet. An infrared gun cannot go in the cup, so check it another way: point it at the surface of the ice slush in the cup, with the lens close, and see if it is near 32°F. If it is off by more than the spec sheet allows, or by more than 3 to 4°F, keep it for scanning only and do not trust it for a limit. Test both on a schedule, weekly or monthly, and write the result down. For what the label "HACCP approved" means on a thermometer, read HACCP approved thermometer.

Mistakes we see with infrared guns

Questions

Can I use an infrared thermometer for a food safety log?

Only for surface or scan lines. A limit such as 41°F or 135°F is a limit on the food itself, and that number comes from a probe in the food.

Are infrared thermometers accurate?

They are accurate for the surface they see, under the conditions on the spec sheet. Steam, shiny steel, distance and lids all change the reading. A model's stated accuracy does not cover those.

Why do health inspectors use probes?

Because the rule is about the middle of the food. An inspector may also use an infrared device on walls and equipment.

Is an infrared thermometer good for a walk-in cooler?

It can find a warm shelf or a leaking door seal quickly. For the log, use the unit's own thermometer, tested against a cup of water in the unit. See the walk-in cooler temperature log.

Do I have to sanitize a probe between foods?

Yes. Wipe or wash and sanitize it between raw and cooked foods and between different foods, so it does not carry germs from one to another [3].

How often should I test my thermometers?

At least weekly for a probe in daily use, and after any drop. The Food Code does not set a number of days; your plan should state yours and record each test.

If you want the temperature logs and the plan set up for your menu, see your plan.

Sources

  1. FDA, "Using a Food Thermometer" and the Food Code on measuring device types. https://www.fda.gov/food/buy-store-serve-safe-food/use-food-thermometer
  2. USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service, Kitchen thermometers, including the ice-water test. https://www.fsis.usda.gov/food-safety/safe-food-handling-and-preparation/food-safety-basics/kitchen-thermometers
  3. FDA Food Code 2022: temperature measuring devices, cooking, holding, cooling and receiving limits. https://www.fda.gov/food/retail-food-protection/fda-food-code

All food safety guides