Restaurant food safety audits: who does them, what they check and how to get ready
A restaurant food safety audit is a planned check of your kitchen against a standard: it looks at what staff do, what the temperatures are and what your records show. There are three kinds: a health department inspection, a private audit by an outside company, and a self-audit that you run yourself.
This guide is for restaurant owners and managers who have an audit coming, were asked for one by a landlord, franchisor or insurer, or want to know if paying an auditor is worth it. It explains each kind, what is checked, how to prepare and how to pick an auditor. To see the temperature log your auditor will ask for, find your restaurant and see your plan.
Want the temperature log an auditor asks for, ready for your menu? See your plan, built from your menu. No card.
Three kinds of restaurant food safety audit
| Health inspection | Private audit | Self-audit | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who | Your city, county or state health department | An outside company or consultant you or a third party hire | You or your manager |
| Why | It is the law; the result may be public and tied to your permit | A chain, franchisor, landlord, insurer or buyer asks for it, or you want a second view | To find problems before anyone else does |
| Notice | Usually none | Often scheduled, sometimes a surprise visit | Whenever you choose |
| Standard | Your local food code, based on the FDA Food Code [1] | Your local code, a brand standard or a plan you wrote | Your own checklist |
| Cost | Covered by your permit fee | Varies by company and scope; ask for a written quote | Staff time |
Rules and scoring differ by place. As one example, New York City gives points for each violation, and the total sets an A, B or C grade, with 0 to 13 points an A [2]. Your area may use a different system, so read your health department's scoring page.
What an audit checks
Whatever the name, auditors look at the same few things. The FDA and CDC group the main causes of food-borne illness into five risk factors: food from unsafe sources, food not cooked enough, food held at the wrong temperature, contaminated equipment or cross-contact, and poor hygiene by workers [3]. A good audit has a question for each, plus the paperwork.
- Observation. The auditor watches. Do cooks wash hands at the right moments? Is raw chicken stored below ready-to-eat food? Is the sanitizer at the right strength?
- Measurement. They probe food and read cooler air temperatures. Cold at 41°F or below and hot at 135°F or above are the usual limits [1].
- Interviews. They ask a cook or the person in charge things like "What do you do if the cooler is at 46°F?" or "When must a sick worker stay home?"
- Records. They ask to see logs: temperatures, cooling, receiving, sanitizer, thermometer checks, cleaning, pest control and training. See the restaurant temperature log sheet and food safety training records.
- Documents. Permits, manager certificates, the written plan if you have one, and supplier information.
Is a private audit worth paying for?
It can be, in a few cases:
- A buyer, franchisor, landlord or insurer requires it. Then the question is only who does it.
- You have had a bad inspection and want an outside view before the re-check.
- You use a special process (sous vide, curing, vacuum packing) and want someone to check the plan and records.
- You are opening more than one location and want one standard.
It is usually not worth it if you just want a pass on your next health inspection and have not yet tried a self-audit. A careful manager with a good checklist finds most of the same problems. See the HACCP audit checklist and the restaurant food safety inspection checklist. A consultant who writes and checks plans is covered in HACCP consultant for a restaurant.
How to choose a private auditor
We found no single price list for restaurant audits, so we do not quote one. Prices depend on the company, the size of the kitchen and the number of visits. Ask each firm for these in writing:
- What standard they audit against (your local code, a brand standard, something else), and who owns that standard.
- How many visits, how long each takes, and whether they are announced.
- What you get at the end: a score, a list of findings, photos, a corrective action plan.
- Who the auditor is, what training they hold and whether they have worked in a kitchen.
- Total cost, and what costs extra (a re-visit, a report, travel).
- Whether the audit is separate from training or selling you software. Be careful when the auditor also sells the fix.
Get two or three quotes. If a client asked for the audit, ask the client which firms they accept before you pay for one.
How to get ready: the 7-day plan
Seven days before
- Print your logs for the past 90 days. Fill in any real gaps with a dated note, never made-up numbers.
- Check that the manager's certificate and food handler cards are in date.
- Find the permit, pest control reports and supplier list.
Three days before
- Walk the kitchen with a checklist. Fix the easy findings the same day.
- Calibrate every probe thermometer (calibration log).
- Stock test strips, soap, paper towels, gloves, labels and a sanitizer bucket at each station.
The day before
- Brief the crew for 15 minutes: hands, labels, probing, who to call the person in charge.
- Check coolers and walk-in readings. If one is warm, see walk-in cooler not reaching temperature.
On the day
- Have the person in charge walk with the auditor. Answer plainly; say "I do not know, let me check" if you do not.
- Do not hide or redo logs while the auditor is there. Never change an old record.
- Fix what can be fixed on the spot and say so.
A one-hour self-audit you can run this week
Do it when the kitchen is busy, not just when it is clean. Bring a clipboard, a probe thermometer and sanitizer test strips.
| Minutes | What to do | What you are looking for |
|---|---|---|
| 0 to 10 | Read the last 30 days of logs | Gaps, identical numbers, bad readings with no action written |
| 10 to 25 | Probe cold and hot pans on the line and prep cooler | Cold at 41°F or below, hot at 135°F or above |
| 25 to 35 | Walk coolers and dry storage | Storage order, date marks, covered food, floor clearance, door seals |
| 35 to 45 | Watch hands and gloves at two stations | Hand washing at the right moments, glove changes, bare hands on ready-to-eat food |
| 45 to 55 | Check dish area, sanitizer, hand sinks, thermometers | Test strip reading, soap and towels, hand sink not blocked, probe in ice water reads 32°F |
| 55 to 60 | Ask two staff three questions | Limits, what to do when a number is wrong, when a sick worker stays home |
Write each finding as one line: what, where, who fixes it, by when. A simple score helps you see change: count passes out of the checks you made, and compare next month. If the number goes down, find out why before you look at the next one.
How an audit differs from your daily checks
Daily checks are what staff do to keep food safe: probing, logging, labeling. An audit asks a different question: are the daily checks really happening, and are they the right ones? Checking the program itself is called verification. A list of verification steps, from daily record reviews to yearly plan reviews, is in HACCP verification activities. An audit is one of those steps, done by someone with fresh eyes.
The findings that come up most
- Cold food above 41°F on the line or in a prep cooler.
- Missing date marks on prepped or opened foods.
- No test strips, or sanitizer too weak or too strong.
- Thermometers that were never calibrated.
- Raw food stored above ready-to-eat food.
- Logs with gaps or numbers that are all identical.
- No written action next to a bad reading.
- Hand sink blocked or without soap or towels.
These match what many inspection reports cite. The most cited items are explained in restaurant food safety violations.
What to do with the findings
- Sort them. Fix now (a missing label), fix this week (a broken door seal), plan for (a new cooler).
- Write a corrective action for each: what, who, by when.
- Fix the cause, not just the symptom. If three coolers read warm, check the door gaskets and the habit of propping the door, not just the readings.
- Tell the crew what was found and what changed.
- Re-check in two weeks and write the result down.
- Keep the report with your records. See HACCP record keeping.
For the full system the audit is checking, see the restaurant food safety program guide.
Related: a practice walk before the real visit is covered in mock health inspection, and the tools that run audits on a phone in food safety audit software.
Questions
What is a restaurant food safety audit?
A planned check of your kitchen's practices, temperatures and records against a standard, done by a health inspector, an outside auditor or yourself.
What is the difference between an inspection and an audit?
An inspection is done by the health department and is tied to your permit. An audit is usually a private check, done by a company you or a client hire, or by you.
How often should a restaurant do a food safety audit?
A self-audit every month is a good habit, and a full one each year. Health inspections follow your area's schedule. Private audits follow what the client or insurer asks for.
How much does a restaurant food safety audit cost?
It varies by firm and scope, and we found no standard price. Ask for a written quote that lists visits, report and extras.
What records will an auditor ask for?
Temperature logs, cooling and receiving logs, sanitizer and thermometer checks, cleaning and pest control records, training records and permits.
Can I audit my own restaurant?
Yes. Use a checklist, walk the kitchen with fresh eyes, test staff with a few questions and write down every finding with a fix and a date.
For temperature logs and a plan written from your own menu, see your plan.
Sources
- FDA Food Code 2022: time and temperature limits (3-401, 3-501), person in charge (2-101). https://www.fda.gov/food/retail-food-protection/fda-food-code
- NYC Health, Restaurant grading: how it works (points and letter grades). https://www.nyc.gov/site/doh/business/food-operators/letter-grading-for-restaurants.page
- FDA, Report on the Occurrence of Foodborne Illness Risk Factors in Fast Food and Full-Service Restaurants, 2013-2014. https://www.fda.gov/food/retail-food-protection/fda-report-occurrence-foodborne-illness-risk-factors-fast-food-and-full-service-restaurants-2013-2014