Find my businessStart

Lightspeed vs Toast for restaurants: plans, card rates, contracts and which costs less

Lightspeed vs Toast comes down to three numbers: the monthly software fee, the card rate and the contract. Toast lists a $0 Starter Kit and a Point of Sale plan from $69 a month per terminal, with 2.49% + 15¢ on in-person cards, and contracts that run one to three years [1]. Lightspeed Restaurant lists $69 (Starter), $189 (Essential) and $399 (Premium) a month per location, with 2.6% + 10¢ in person, and software that is often month to month [1] [2]. On a $25,000 month at a $25 ticket, Toast's paid plan costs about $842 and Lightspeed Essential about $939. Confirm both in a written quote.

If what you need is a menu page that takes pickup orders, you do not need either one: you can build a free menu site with pickup ordering from a photo of your menu. Below: the plans side by side, a month worked out, where the cheaper one flips, online orders, hardware, contracts, features, and who each fits.

Lightspeed vs Toast: the fees side by side

ToastLightspeed Restaurant
Entry planStarter Kit, $0 a month, higher card rates [1]Starter, about $69 a month per location [2]
Main planPoint of Sale, from $69 a month per terminal [1]Essential, $189 a month per location [1] [2]
Top planCustom quotes for multi-location groups [1]Premium $399 a month; Enterprise custom [1] [2]
In-person card rate2.49% + 15¢ on the monthly plan; 3.09% to 3.69% + 15¢ pay-as-you-go [1]2.6% + 10¢ (varies by market and plan) [1]
Online card rateAbout 3.5% + 15¢ as reported in our Toast guide [4]2.9% + 30¢ [1]
Keyed card rateQuoted by channel [1]3.5% + 30¢ [1]
Payment processorToast Payments required [1]Lightspeed Payments or other options, by market [1]
ContractTypically 1 to 3 years [1]Software often month to month, plus a payments agreement [1]
Kitchen screenQuoted with hardwareAbout $30 a screen a month [1]
Chargeback feeNot listed on the pages we read$15 [2]

Sources disagree on Lightspeed's entry price: one review lists Starter at $69, another site lists $59, and a third lists $89, $149 and $289 tiers [1] [2]. Prices also differ by country, so make sure a quote is in US dollars for a US plan. Toast's own plan names are inconsistent across reviews too. Use the table as a range and ask for a quote that names the plan, the number of terminals and the term.

A month on each: three sizes

An illustration, not your numbers: one terminal or register, every sale a card swiped or tapped, an average ticket of $25. That is 400, 1,000 and 2,400 tickets. Hardware, add-ons and online orders are left out. Toast is on its $69 plan at 2.49% + 15¢; Lightspeed is on Starter at the smallest size and Essential above it, at 2.6% + 10¢.

Monthly card salesTicketsToast ($69, 2.49% + 15¢)Lightspeed (2.6% + 10¢)
$10,000400$378.00$369.00 on Starter, $489.00 on Essential
$25,0001,000$841.50$939.00 on Essential
$60,0002,400$1,923.00$1,989.00 on Essential

The sums at $25,000: Toast is 2.49% × $25,000 = $622.50, plus 1,000 × 15¢ = $150, plus $69, total $841.50. Lightspeed Essential is 2.6% × $25,000 = $650, plus 1,000 × 10¢ = $100, plus $189, total $939. At $10,000 on Starter, Lightspeed is $260 + $40 + $69 = $369. Toast's $0 Starter Kit at 3.09% + 15¢ would be $309 + $60 = $369 at the same size, and $922.50 at $25,000, so it is cheapest only for the smallest place [1].

Where Lightspeed stops costing more

The two systems charge in opposite ways. Toast's percentage is lower (2.49% against 2.6%), but its fixed part is higher (15¢ against 10¢). On a $25 ticket Lightspeed costs 2.75¢ more in percentage and 5¢ less in fixed fees, so it is 2.25¢ cheaper per ticket on card fees alone. Essential is $120 a month more than Toast's plan, so it needs $120 ÷ 2.25¢ = about 5,333 tickets, or about $133,000 a month, to catch up. For nearly every independent restaurant, Toast's paid plan costs less on these numbers.

A bigger ticket helps Lightspeed. The 0.11-point gap in percentage equals 5¢ at a $45.45 ticket, so above that average the percentage gap outweighs the fixed-fee gap in Lightspeed's favour per ticket. A bar or fine-dining room with a $60 ticket saves more per ticket on Lightspeed, but the plan gap still has to be paid back. Rerun the sum with your own average ticket, which you can find by dividing last month's card sales by the number of sales.

Online ordering on Lightspeed and Toast

Toast includes online ordering natively on paid plans according to one comparison, while our Toast ordering guide reports an add-on of about $75 a month on top of the POS plan [1] [4]. Lightspeed offers online ordering from the Essential plan up, by region and with integrations [1] [2]. Neither takes a commission per order, but each charges card fees. On a $25 online order:

OrderToast at 3.5% + 15¢Lightspeed at 2.9% + 30¢
$25$1.03$1.03
$40$1.55$1.46
$15$0.68$0.74

At $25 the two are the same to the cent. Smaller orders favour Toast's lower fixed fee, bigger ones favour Lightspeed's lower percentage. The monthly add-on is the larger difference, and it depends on your plan. Compare it with a marketplace at 15% to 30% in our DoorDash commission guide. For delivery, Toast Delivery Services is listed at a flat $7.49 per order [1].

Hardware and setup

ItemToastLightspeed
HandheldToast Go 2, about $494 [1]iPad about $349 [1]
TerminalKits about $719 to $944 [1]Smart terminal or reader about $399 [1]
Stand or kiosk22-inch kiosk about $1,034 [1]Stand about $199 [1]
PrintersIn kits or extraAbout $200 to $400 each [1]
SetupSetup service $849 for 1 to 2 terminals, $1,049 for 3 or more; onboarding 2 to 4 weeks [1]Quick iPad setup; bundles quote-based [1]

Toast uses its own rugged hardware and needs Toast Payments. Lightspeed runs on iPads, which gives you more freedom to change hardware and, in some markets, processor [1]. Toast's setup service adds a one-time cost that Lightspeed's quick start may avoid, which can decide a first-year comparison for a one-terminal place. Spread both over 36 months before you compare.

Contracts: the difference a price page hides

Toast contracts typically run one to three years [1]. Lightspeed's software is often month to month, but you still sign a payments agreement and terms vary by region and package [1]. A shorter term is only worth money if you might leave. A restaurant in its first year can value an exit; one with a stable room may take the longer term in return for a lower rate. Ask each rep:

  1. What is the term on this exact plan, and when does it renew?
  2. What does early termination cost, in dollars?
  3. Is the card rate fixed, and for how long?
  4. Do I own the hardware, and can it run another processor?
  5. What is the setup, onboarding and training fee?
  6. Can I export my menu and sales history?

Features: where each one is stronger

Lightspeed vs Toast: who each one fits

Toast fits a full-service or hybrid restaurant with tables, courses and a busy kitchen, and an owner who will accept a multi-year contract for those tools and a lower card rate at ordinary ticket sizes. Lightspeed fits a place that prefers iPads and modular add-ons, a café or counter concept, a group with several concepts, or a high-ticket room where its fee structure favours it. For a small place that mostly takes counter sales and pickup orders, both are more than the job needs: see Square against Clover or commission-free online ordering.

Next in this series: Lightspeed against Square, Lightspeed against Clover, Lightspeed alternatives and Toast against Square. Each system on its own: Toast pricing and Lightspeed Restaurant pricing. All guides: the guides hub.

Questions

Is Lightspeed cheaper than Toast?

Not on a typical small-restaurant month. At $25,000 of card sales on a $25 ticket, Toast's paid plan is about $842 and Lightspeed Essential about $939. Lightspeed's Starter plan is cheaper but leaves out features such as online ordering [2].

Does Lightspeed or Toast have a contract?

Toast typically asks for one to three years. Lightspeed's software is often month to month, with a payments agreement; confirm both in writing [1].

Which has lower card rates, Lightspeed or Toast?

Toast's monthly-plan in-person rate is 2.49% + 15¢ against Lightspeed's 2.6% + 10¢. Rates depend on volume and market [1].

Can I use my own processor with Toast or Lightspeed?

Toast requires Toast Payments. Lightspeed supports other options depending on the market [1].

Which is better for a small restaurant?

Often neither: a $0 Square plan or a free pickup page costs less if you do not need coursing, kitchen routing or deep inventory.

Do either charge a commission on online orders?

No, each charges card processing only; the difference is the add-on or plan fee.

Taking pickup orders without a contract? Build your menu site free from a photo of your menu; diners pay you at the counter.

Sources

  1. Toast vs. Lightspeed: honest POS comparison, pricing and features, UpMenu, updated May 12, 2026 (a rival ordering vendor; plans, rates, hardware, contracts, support).
  2. Lightspeed vs. Square POS, business.com, updated Sept 17, 2026 (Lightspeed plans, rates, chargeback fee).
  3. Toast pricing, our guide, with its sources.
  4. Toast online ordering fees, our guide, with its sources.
  5. Lightspeed Restaurant pricing, our guide, with its sources.

Prices change and resellers differ. Confirm with each vendor and read your own written quote.