Menufy vs Square for restaurants: what each costs a month and who fits
Menufy vs Square comes down to a flat monthly plan with a fee per order against a $0 plan that takes a cut of each card payment. Menufy is reported at $149 a month on an annual contract, or $179 month to month, plus a $1.75 fee on each online order that you or your diner can pay [1]. Square Online is $0 a month on its Free plan and about 3.3% + 30¢ on each online card order [2]. At 300 orders of $30 a month ($9,000), Square Free costs $387 and Menufy costs $486.50 to $1,011.50 with card fees, depending on who pays its $1.75.
This is for an independent restaurant that wants regulars to order on its own page and is picking the cheapest tool that does the job. If you only want pickup orders from a menu page with no monthly plan, you can build a menu site with pickup ordering from a photo of your menu. Below: both price lists, a month at three sizes, what each includes, when Square Plus helps, who each fits, what to ask, and a short FAQ.
Menufy vs Square: the price lists side by side
| Menufy | Square Online | |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly plan | $149 annual, $179 month to month, reported [1] | Free $0; Plus $49 per location; Premium $149 per location [2] |
| Fee per order | $1.75 convenience fee, which can be passed to the diner [1] | None; the cost is the card rate [2] |
| Online card rate | About 2.75% + 30¢ in one review; Clover users keep Clover's processing [1] | 3.3% + 30¢ on Free; 2.9% + 30¢ on Plus and Premium [2] |
| What it is | Ordering page and marketing tools [1] | Ordering page that shares your menu with the Square register [2] |
| Delivery | Says it negotiated 12.5% commission with DoorDash and Uber Eats for partners; we could not verify [1] | Your own drivers, or an on-demand courier booked per order [2] |
| Contract | Cheaper rate on an annual term; ask the length [1] | Monthly plans; no contract in our sources [2] |
Menufy's figures come from third-party listings and Menufy's own posts, not one printed price page, so they can be out of date. Square's come from a 2026 pricing breakdown and its help pages. The long versions are Menufy pricing and Square online ordering for restaurants.
A month at three sizes
We worked a month at a $30 average order, all paid by card online, with card fees included on both sides. For Menufy we use the reported 2.75% + 30¢; for Square, the plan's own rate.
| Orders a month | Sales | Menufy, fee absorbed | Menufy, fee passed on | Square Free | Square Plus |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 150 | $4,500 | $149 + $262.50 + $168.75 = $580.25 | $149 + $168.75 = $317.75 | $193.50 | $224.50 |
| 300 | $9,000 | $149 + $525 + $337.50 = $1,011.50 | $149 + $337.50 = $486.50 | $387 | $400 |
| 600 | $18,000 | $149 + $1,050 + $675 = $1,874 | $149 + $675 = $824 | $774 | $751 |
The sums: Menufy's fee is orders times $1.75 (300 × $1.75 = $525); its card cost on 300 orders is 2.75% of $9,000 = $247.50 plus 300 × 30¢ = $90, so $337.50 [1]. Square Free is 3.3% of sales plus 30¢ an order: $297 + $90 = $387 on 300 orders. Plus is $49 plus 2.9% ($261) plus $90 = $400 [2].
What the table says: Square Free is the lowest at 150 and 300 orders, even against Menufy with the fee passed on. At 600 orders Square Plus is $751 against Menufy's $824 passed on. On these sums Menufy does not come out ahead at any size; it can only win when its quoted card rate is lower than yours, so ask for your own quote and rerun the table. If you absorb Menufy's fee, it costs about two and a half times Square Free at 300 orders.
When Square Plus beats Square Free
Plus lowers the online card rate from 3.3% to 2.9%, a gap of 0.4% of online sales, and costs $49. It saves money only when 0.4% of your online sales is more than $49: above $12,250 a month [2]. In the table, Plus costs more at 150 and 300 orders and less at 600. Below that level, pick Plus for QR code ordering at the table, not to save on fees.
Who pays the fee on Menufy?
On Menufy you choose whether the diner or you pays the $1.75 [1]. That is 5.8% of a $30 order, 7% of a $25 order and almost 20% of a $9 coffee. A flat fee hurts small orders most. On Square there is no per-order fee for the diner in our sources; delivery orders carry a delivery fee [2]. Pass the fee on for a month and count orders, then absorb it for a month and count again. Regulars who see a fee they did not see at the counter sometimes call instead.
What each one includes
Menufy
The plan name, Marketing + Online Ordering, says what you buy: an ordering page and marketing tools [1]. It works with the register you have, including Clover. Ask what the marketing tools are, who runs them and whether the offers are included in the price.
Square
Square is a register that also sells online. Menu items live in the item library your POS uses, so a sold-out item goes off both [2]. You turn on pickup, delivery or both and set hours. Orders appear on your Square POS, a kitchen screen or a printer. Delivery is either your own drivers or an on-demand courier, and one location runs one kind at a time [2]. A kitchen screen is $30 a device on Plus and $20 on Premium [2].
The honest difference
If you already ring up sales on Square, its ordering page costs nothing to try, and it is hard to beat on price. If you use a different register and want to keep it, Menufy gives you ordering without changing it, and a marketing layer on top. Neither promises new customers.
Which fits which restaurant
Menufy fits if
- You have a register you want to keep, and it is not Square.
- Your average order is above about $35, so $1.75 is under 5%, and you can pass the fee on.
- You want marketing tools bundled with the ordering page.
Square fits if
- You already use Square at the counter, or would switch to it.
- You want ordering at $0 a month and are happy to set it up yourself.
- Your online volume is small or still unknown.
Neither fits if
- Most of your diners pay in cash at the counter. A free pickup page costs $0 online.
- You want a team to build and run the whole online side. Look at Menufy vs Owner.com instead.
More on the field: Menufy alternatives, ChowNow vs Square and free online ordering systems.
Does your average order change the answer?
Yes. Menufy's $1.75 is a flat fee and Square's rate is a percentage, so the order size moves the comparison. Take 300 orders a month and Menufy with the fee passed on to the diner, so you only pay the $149 plan and the card cost. At a $20 order ($6,000 of sales) Menufy is $149 + $165 + $90 = $404, and Square Free is $198 + $90 = $288. At a $45 order ($13,500) Menufy is $149 + $371.25 + $90 = $610.25, and Square Free is $445.50 + $90 = $535.50; Square Plus is $49 + $391.50 + $90 = $530.50. The card sums use Menufy's reported 2.75% + 30¢ and Square's 3.3% + 30¢ on Free [1] [2].
So a bigger average order does not rescue Menufy on our numbers: its $149 plan is a fixed cost that Square's Free plan does not have. What a bigger order does is shrink Menufy's $1.75 if you absorb it. At $45 the fee is 3.9% of the order, at $20 it is 8.75%. If your diners order for four people, the fee matters less; if they order a coffee and a muffin, it matters a lot.
What to count in your own month first
Before you pay for either, count four things from the last four weeks: how many orders you would move online, your average order, how many of those diners pay by card, and how many ask for delivery. Then put the numbers in the table above. If the card share is low, both bills shrink, and a free pickup page where the diner pays at the counter becomes the cheapest of all. If delivery is most of the orders, read the courier fees on Square's delivery options and Menufy's own written terms, because a trip fee can be larger than either plan.
Questions to ask both
- What is the total I pay a month for the plan I would use, in writing, with every per-order fee?
- What is the online card rate and who is the processor?
- Is there a setup fee?
- What is the term, how do I cancel, and is a prepaid term refundable?
- Who owns my domain, my menu and my customer list if I leave?
Register the domain yourself, in your name, and point it at the vendor. That keeps the exit open whichever you pick.
Questions
Is Square cheaper than Menufy?
At 150 and 300 orders of $30, yes, even when the diner pays Menufy's fee: $387 against $486.50 at 300 orders [1] [2]. At 600 orders Square Plus is still lower than Menufy with the fee passed on.
Does Menufy charge commission?
Menufy's model is a plan plus a $1.75 convenience fee per order, not a percentage commission on the order [1].
Does Square charge commission?
Not a marketplace commission. Square charges its card rate on each online order, 3.3% + 30¢ on Free [2].
Can I use Menufy with a Square register?
We did not find a source that says so. Ask Menufy which registers it connects to; the one we found is Clover [1].
Which is better for a small restaurant?
If you take under about 100 online orders a month, Square Free or a free pickup page usually costs less than a $149 plan.
Want pickup orders without a monthly plan? Build your menu site from a photo of your menu.
Sources
- Menufy pricing, our guide, with its sources (Menufy's own posts and third-party listings, read Nov 2026).
- Square online ordering for restaurants, our guide, with its sources (Square's restaurant pricing page and help pages; a 2026 pricing breakdown).
Related: Owner.com vs Square, Toast vs Square and all our guides.
Prices change and vendors differ. Confirm with each and read your own written quote.