Menufy vs Toast for restaurants: what each costs a month and who fits
Menufy vs Toast is not a like-for-like choice: Menufy is an online ordering plan, and Toast is a full register system with online ordering added on. Menufy is reported at $149 a month on an annual contract, or $179 month to month, plus a $1.75 fee on each online order that you or your diner can pay [1]. Toast's Point of Sale plan is $69 a month per terminal, with online ordering reported near $75 a month more and online cards at about 3.5% + 15¢ [2]. At 300 orders of $30 a month ($9,000), Toast's online side is about $504 with card fees; Menufy is $486.50 to $1,011.50 with card fees, depending on who pays the $1.75.
This is for an independent restaurant deciding whether to buy ordering alone or to change its register too. If you only need pickup orders from a menu page and no monthly plan, you can build a menu site with pickup ordering from a photo of your menu. Below: both price lists, the part that is hardware, a month at three sizes, what each includes, who each fits, what to ask, and a short FAQ.
Menufy vs Toast: the price lists side by side
| Menufy | Toast | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Ordering page and marketing tools [1] | Register, kitchen screens, card processing and add-on modules [2] |
| Monthly plan | $149 annual, $179 month to month, reported [1] | $0 Starter Kit; $69 per terminal Point of Sale; custom for groups [2] |
| Online ordering | Included in the plan [1] | An add-on, reported near $75 a month [2] |
| Fee per order | $1.75 convenience fee, which can be passed to the diner [1] | No per-order commission; the cost is the card rate [3] |
| Online card rate | About 2.75% + 30¢ in one review; Clover users keep Clover's processing [1] | Often about 3.5% + 15¢ or more, reported [2] |
| Hardware | None needed to take online orders; works with the register you have, including Clover [1] | Bought separately: a countertop terminal about $799 to $1,199 [2] |
| Contract | Cheaper rate on an annual term; ask the length [1] | Reviews mention multi-year terms and early exit fees; no length or fee in our sources [2] |
Neither company prints all of this on one page, so the numbers come from third-party listings and guides and can be out of date. The long versions are Menufy pricing, Toast pricing and Toast online ordering.
The big difference: Menufy plugs into a register, Toast is the register
Menufy sells you an ordering page. You still need a way to ring up sales at the counter, and you can keep the one you have [1]. Toast sells you the whole counter: terminals, kitchen screens, card processing and then online ordering as one more module [2]. So "Menufy vs Toast" is really two questions. First: do I want to change my register? If no, Toast's online ordering is only worth pricing if it comes with a register you were going to buy anyway. Second, if yes: what does the online side cost inside each?
If you do not plan to change your register, you are not choosing between these two. You are choosing between ordering plans like Menufy and Owner.com or ChowNow and Menufy. If you are already on Toast, the question is simply whether its own ordering is cheaper than adding Menufy, and the table below says when.
A month at three sizes
We worked a month at a $30 average order, all paid by card online, one terminal on Toast's $69 plan, ordering add-on at about $75. These are the online side only: the register's counter sales and hardware are left out, because Menufy does not charge for them.
| Orders a month | Sales | Menufy, fee absorbed | Menufy, fee passed on | Toast online |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 150 | $4,500 | $149 + $262.50 + $168.75 = $580.25 | $149 + $168.75 = $317.75 | $69 + $75 + $157.50 + $22.50 = $324 |
| 300 | $9,000 | $149 + $525 + $337.50 = $1,011.50 | $149 + $337.50 = $486.50 | $69 + $75 + $315 + $45 = $504 |
| 600 | $18,000 | $149 + $1,050 + $675 = $1,874 | $149 + $675 = $824 | $69 + $75 + $630 + $90 = $864 |
The sums: Menufy's fee is orders times $1.75 (300 × $1.75 = $525). Menufy's card cost uses the reported 2.75% + 30¢: on 300 orders, 2.75% of $9,000 is $247.50 and 300 × 30¢ is $90, so $337.50 [1]. Toast's card cost uses 3.5% + 15¢: 3.5% of $9,000 is $315 and 300 × 15¢ is $45 [2].
What the table says: if you absorb Menufy's $1.75, Toast's online side is cheaper at every size. If you pass the fee on, Menufy is a little lower at every size, by $6.25 at 150 orders, $17.50 at 300 and $40 at 600. That is small next to a month's card rate differences, so your actual card quote and what your diners tolerate matter more than the brand.
Where Toast's bill really grows
The online side is the small part of a Toast bill. A single terminal is about $799 to $1,199, a printer $200 to $350 and a kitchen screen $599 to $1,199, so a counter-service start is about $1,600 to $2,750 in hardware alone [2]. Toast's guide-level estimate for a small café is $300 to $700 a month all in, and $1,000 to $2,000 or more for a full-service restaurant [2]. If you take that bill to replace a register you already own, Menufy's $149 is a much smaller change. If your register is old or breaking, Toast's hardware may be a cost you were going to have anyway.
Who pays the fee on Menufy?
On Menufy you choose whether the diner or you pays the $1.75 [1]. That is 5.8% of a $30 order and 7% of a $25 order. On Toast there is no per-order fee for the diner at all in our sources; the cost is in the card rate [2]. Pass the fee on for a month and count orders, then absorb it for a month and count again. Regulars who see a fee they did not see at the counter sometimes call instead.
What each one includes
Menufy
The plan name, Marketing + Online Ordering, says what you buy: an ordering page and marketing tools [1]. It is a lighter product than a done-for-you service. It connects to Clover for payments, in which case Clover's processing applies. Ask what the marketing tools are and who runs them.
Toast
Toast is built for restaurants: orders flow to the kitchen screens and printers it sells, and online ordering is a module on the same menu and the same reports [2]. Other modules, such as gift cards, catering, loyalty and payroll, are billed separately and are not priced in one place [2]. That is helpful when you want it all in one system, and costly when you only wanted ordering.
Which fits which restaurant
Menufy fits if
- You have a register you like and want to add ordering on your own page.
- You want the lowest fixed cost and can live with a per-order fee, or can pass it on.
- You run Clover and want your processing to stay as it is.
Toast fits if
- You are buying or replacing a register anyway and want ordering, kitchen screens and card processing in one system.
- You do 300 or more online orders a month and want no per-order fee.
- You have a kitchen with several stations and want tickets routed to screens.
Neither fits if
- You have a few online orders a day. A $149 plan or a $69 plan plus add-on is a lot for a handful of orders.
- You want to try online ordering before paying for it.
More on the field: Toast alternatives, Menufy alternatives and free online ordering systems.
Questions to ask both
- What is the total I pay a month for what I would use, in writing, with every module and per-order fee?
- What is the online card rate and who is the processor?
- Is there a setup or onboarding fee? Toast's Starter Kit onboarding is reported at up to $95 an hour [2].
- What is the term, how do I cancel, and what does it cost to leave early?
- Who owns my domain, my menu and my customer list if I leave?
Register the domain yourself, in your name, and point it at the vendor. That keeps the exit open whichever you pick.
Questions
Is Menufy cheaper than Toast?
For ordering alone, Menufy's plan is $149 against Toast's $69 plus about $75 for ordering. Add the $1.75 order fee and Toast's online side is lower at every size we worked unless the diner pays the fee [1] [2].
Does Toast charge commission on online orders?
No per-order commission in our sources. The cost is the card rate, about 3.5% + 15¢ for online orders as reported, and the add-on fee [2] [3].
Does Menufy charge commission?
Menufy's model is a plan plus a $1.75 convenience fee per order, not a percentage commission [1].
Can I use Menufy with Toast?
We did not find a source that says so. Ask Menufy which registers it connects to; the one we found is Clover [1].
Which is better for a small restaurant?
If you take under about 100 online orders a month, a free pickup page or ordering inside your current register often costs less than either.
Want pickup orders without a monthly plan? Build your menu site from a photo of your menu.
Sources
- Menufy pricing, our guide, with its sources (Menufy's own posts and third-party listings, read Nov 2026).
- Toast pricing, our guide, with its sources (a May 2026 UpMenu guide and other third-party reports; Toast does not publish its processing rates).
- Toast online ordering, our guide, with its sources.
Related: ChowNow vs Toast, Owner.com vs Toast and all our guides.
Prices change and vendors differ. Confirm with each and read your own written quote.