Find my businessStart

SpotOn vs Square for restaurants: plans, card rates, contracts and which costs less

SpotOn vs Square comes down to a plan fee against a card rate. Square's restaurant plans are Free at $0, Plus at $49 and Premium at $149 a month, with in-person cards at 2.6%, 2.5% and 2.4% + 15¢. SpotOn lists POS Essentials at $55 a station at 2.45% + 15¢ and All-In at $0 with hardware included at 2.79% + 20¢ and a two-year minimum [1] [2]. On a $25,000 month at a $25 ticket and one station, Square Free costs about $800, SpotOn Essentials $817.50 and SpotOn All-In $897.50. Confirm each in a written quote: these are reported figures.

If what you need is orders from your own menu page, you can build a menu site with pickup ordering from a photo of your menu and skip the POS contract. Below: the plans side by side, a month at three sizes, the tickets where each one wins, online orders, hardware, the contract, and who each fits.

SpotOn vs Square: the plans side by side

Square for RestaurantsSpotOn
PlansFree $0, Plus $49, Premium $149 a month per location [2]All-In $0 a station, POS Essentials $55 a station, Build Your Own by quote [1]
In-person card rate2.6% + 15¢ Free, 2.5% + 15¢ Plus, 2.4% + 15¢ Premium [2]2.79% + 20¢ All-In; 2.45% + 15¢ Essentials (Amex 3.19% + 15¢) [1]
Online or keyed card3.3% + 30¢ Free; 2.9% + 30¢ Plus and Premium [2] [3]3.79% + 20¢ keyed on All-In; 3.45% + 15¢ keyed on Essentials; online rate not printed [1]
Does a higher plan lower the rate?Yes, by 0.1 of a point a stepYes: Essentials is 0.34 points and 5¢ cheaper than All-In
HardwareBought separately; you can use your own phone or tablet [2]SpotOn's stations from $550 (shown reduced to $415) to $995 (reduced to $750); own hardware not allowed [1]
ContractMonth to month; paid plans have a 30-day trial [2]Essentials month to month; All-In two-year minimum [1]
Online orderingOn every plan [3]SpotOn Order listed as commission-free and included; no online card rate printed [1]
Fees with no numberAdd-ons per device (kitchen screen, kiosk) [2]Implementation; a review reports $1,500 plus $500 for menu entry, unconfirmed [1]

Both lists come from our own pricing guides, which cite each vendor's page and the review sites. Where sources disagree, the guides say so; use the table as a range, not a quote.

A month on each: three sizes

An illustration, not your numbers: one station, every sale a card swiped or tapped, an average ticket of $25, so the fixed cents are charged on 400, 1,000 and 2,400 tickets. Hardware, add-ons and online orders are left out.

Option$10,000 (400)$25,000 (1,000)$60,000 (2,400)
Square Free$320$800$1,920
Square Plus$359$824$1,909
Square Premium$449$899$1,949
SpotOn POS Essentials$360$817.50$1,885
SpotOn All-In$359$897.50$2,154

The sums: Square Free at $25,000 is 2.6% × $25,000 = $650 plus 1,000 × 15¢ = $150, so $800. SpotOn Essentials is 2.45% × $25,000 = $612.50 plus $150 plus the $55 station, so $817.50. All-In is 2.79% × $25,000 = $697.50 plus 1,000 × 20¢ = $200, so $897.50. At $60,000 Square Plus is $1,500 + $360 + $49 = $1,909 and Essentials is $1,470 + $360 + $55 = $1,885.

Where each one starts to win

On a $25 ticket the card cost per sale is 80¢ on Square Free, 77.5¢ on Plus, 76.25¢ on SpotOn Essentials and 89.75¢ on All-In. Add each fixed fee and the months cross at these points:

Hardware is what makes All-In worth a look. Say a SpotOn station at the shown $750, spread over its 24-month term, is $31.25 a month. If you had to buy Square hardware at the same price, All-In would be cheaper only below $31.25 ÷ 9.75¢ = about 321 tickets, about $8,000 a month. If you already own a tablet or phone Square can run on, Square Free wins at once [1] [2].

Online orders: the second bill

Square lists online ordering on every plan, at 3.3% + 30¢ on Free and 2.9% + 30¢ on Plus and Premium. On a $30 pickup order that is $1.29 on Free and $1.17 on Plus [2] [3]. SpotOn lists SpotOn Order as commission-free and included in both plans, but its page prints no rate for an online card, only 3.79% + 20¢ and 3.45% + 15¢ for keyed ones [1]. If a large share of your sales are online, ask SpotOn for the online rate in writing before you compare. Read Square online ordering for restaurants for the Square side. Neither charge is a commission; the delivery apps are a different bill, covered in commission-free online ordering.

The contract is the real difference

Square's plans are month to month and the paid ones come with a 30-day trial, so leaving costs nothing but the switch [2]. SpotOn All-In carries a two-year minimum, and its own page says processing minimums apply [1]. Over 24 months that is 24 × the gap between plans, not just one month's. On the $25,000 month All-In costs $80 more than Essentials and $97.50 more than Square Free's $800, which is $2,340 over the term against Square, before hardware you would otherwise buy. That can still be a fair price for a place that has no cash for stations. It is a price, not a gift.

Ask SpotOn whether you own the stations when the term ends, what leaving early costs and whether card rates are fixed: a review reports a rise in rates from May 1, 2026 that we could not confirm [1].

Restaurant features: where SpotOn aims

SpotOn sells itself as restaurant-specific, with online ordering, a guest app and marketing tools bundled in a Core Bundle that its page prices at $50 a month plus 20 basis points of payment volume per location, capped at $200 [1]. At $25,000 a month in revenue that is $95. Square says the same about its paid plans: more control over staff permissions, tables and floor, and better reports [2]. Independent comparison pages we read were mostly directories and vendor posts. One vendor page says G2 named SpotOn the top restaurant POS in the fall of 2026; it is a vendor claim and we could not confirm it. Two Toolradar pages disagree on which of the two wins.

SpotOn vs Square: who fits which

Square fits a café, truck or small room that wants no contract and the lowest bill at a small volume, or one that already has a tablet. SpotOn Essentials fits a restaurant that does more than about $36,700 a month in card sales and wants a restaurant-only tool set. SpotOn All-In fits an opening with no money for stations, if the two-year term and the higher rate are acceptable.

For other comparisons: Square POS alternatives, SpotOn alternatives, Toast against SpotOn, Square against Clover and the plan detail in Square for Restaurants pricing and SpotOn POS pricing.

How to run your own SpotOn vs Square sum

  1. Take last month's card sales and divide by the number of card sales: that is your ticket.
  2. Multiply sales by each plan's percentage and the number of sales by its cents.
  3. Add the plan fee times your stations.
  4. Add hardware spread over the term, and any add-on you would really use.
  5. Check the answer against the contract: a lower month on a longer term is not the same price.

Questions to ask either rep

  1. Which plan is this quote, what is its term and what renews it?
  2. What are the in-person, online and keyed rates, and are they fixed?
  3. Do I buy or lease the hardware, and can it run another processor?
  4. What are the setup, menu-entry and training fees?
  5. What does cancelling cost, and what do I keep?
  6. Can I export my menu and sales history?

Questions

Is SpotOn cheaper than Square?

Not on the reported figures at a small or middle volume: Square Free is $800 against $817.50 for SpotOn Essentials on a $25,000 month. Above about $36,700 a month Essentials is cheaper [1] [2].

Which has no contract?

Square's plans are month to month. SpotOn Essentials is too; All-In has a two-year minimum [1] [2].

Can I use my own tablet?

With Square you can use your own phone or tablet; SpotOn says you cannot use your own POS hardware [1] [2].

Does either charge a commission on online orders?

No. Both charge card fees, not a share of the order. Square lists 2.9% to 3.3% + 30¢ online; SpotOn does not print an online card rate [1] [2] [3].

Do I need a POS to take pickup orders?

No. A menu page with an order form, where diners pay at the counter, has no monthly fee and no online card fee.

Only need pickup orders? Build your menu site from a photo of your menu, with no contract.

Sources

  1. SpotOn POS pricing, our guide, citing SpotOn's pricing page read Nov 16, 2026.
  2. Square for Restaurants pricing, our guide, with its sources.
  3. Square online ordering for restaurants, our guide, with its sources.
  4. SpotOn vs Square comparison pages (Toolradar, Capterra, SpotOn's blog), search results read Nov 17, 2026; vendor and directory pages.

Related: the best online ordering systems and all our guides.

Prices change and resellers differ. Confirm with each vendor and read your own written quote.