Square POS alternatives for restaurants: 6 options, priced on the same month
The main Square POS alternatives for a restaurant are Clover, Toast, SpotOn, Lightspeed and Revel, plus a plain pickup page if you only need online orders. On a $25,000 month of in-person card sales at a $25 ticket and one station, Square Free costs about $800; Clover Starter costs about $754, SpotOn POS Essentials about $818, Toast's paid plan about $842 and Lightspeed Essential about $939 [1] [2] [3] [4] [5]. Square is the cheapest at small volume and Clover from about $25,000 up, so the reason to switch is usually a feature, not the bill. These figures come from review sites and our own guides, so confirm each in a written quote.
If what you need is orders from your own menu page, you can build a free menu site with pickup ordering from a photo of your menu. Below: why owners look past Square, the options priced together, what you give up with each, when Square is still the better buy, a decision list and the questions to ask.
Why restaurants look for a Square alternative
Four reasons come up in the sources. The first is the card rate: Free is 2.6% + 15¢ in person and the paid plans lower it by only 0.1 of a point each step, so a place with $25,000 of card sales a month pays about $800 on Free and finds the rate does not fall unless it pays $49 or $149 a month more [1]. The second is the online rate, 3.3% + 30¢ on Free, higher than the in-person rate and charged on every pickup order [1]. The third is the add-ons: a kitchen screen is $30 a month a device on Plus and a kiosk $50 [1]. The fourth is depth: Free fits a counter, a truck or a small room, and a sit-down place with courses, a bar and several stations may want a system built only for restaurants.
That list is also why many places stay. Square has no long contract listed, starts on a phone or tablet, and its Free plan is the cheapest of the paid systems below about $10,000 a month.
Six Square POS alternatives on the same month
An illustration, not your numbers: $25,000 of in-person card sales, 1,000 tickets at $25, one terminal or register, hardware and online orders left out.
| Option | Plan | Card rate | Month at $25,000 | Terms to know |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Square Free (baseline) | $0 | 2.6% + 15¢ | $800 | No long term listed [1] |
| Clover Starter | $79 | 2.3% + 10¢ | $754 | Reseller sets price and term; own hardware [2] |
| SpotOn POS Essentials | $55 a station | 2.45% + 15¢ | $817.50 | Month to month; All-In has a 2-year term [3] |
| Toast Point of Sale | $69 a terminal | 2.49% + 15¢ | $842 | 1 to 3 years; Toast Payments required [4] |
| Lightspeed Essential | $189 | 2.6% + 10¢ | $939 | Software often month to month [5] |
| Revel | Quote-based | Not disclosed | Unknown | Older quotes: 3-year contract [6] |
| A free pickup page | $0 | None online; diners pay at the counter | Your counter card fee only | No contract |
The sums: Square Free is 2.6% × $25,000 = $650, plus 1,000 × 15¢ = $150, so $800. Clover Starter is $575 + $100 + $79 = $754. SpotOn Essentials is $612.50 + $150 + $55 = $817.50. Toast is $622.50 + $150 + $69 = $841.50. Lightspeed Essential is $650 + $100 + $189 = $939.
The same options at two other sizes (400 tickets at $10,000 and 2,400 at $60,000), each on the plan that fits the size:
| Option | $10,000 a month | $60,000 a month |
|---|---|---|
| Square Free | $320 | $1,920 (Plus: $1,909) |
| Clover Starter | $349 | $1,699 |
| SpotOn Essentials, one station | $360 | $1,885 |
| Toast Point of Sale | $378 | $1,923 |
| Lightspeed | $369 (Starter) | $1,989 (Essential) |
Square wins at $10,000, loses to Clover by $46 at $25,000 and by about $210 at $60,000. The paid Square plans do not close that gap: Free to Plus breaks even at $49 ÷ 0.1% = $49,000 a month in in-person card sales, and Plus then saves only about $11 at $60,000 [1].
Clover: the lowest reported card rate
Clover is reported at about 2.3% + 10¢ in person on every plan, with plans from $79 a month. It beats Square on cost from about $25,000 a month. You give up Square's start-on-a-tablet ease: Clover needs its own hardware, from about $499 to $1,899 a station, and the plan, rate and term come from the reseller [2]. Read Square against Clover and Clover POS pricing, or the longer list of Clover alternatives.
Toast: the restaurant-only system
Toast is built only for restaurants, with coursing, kitchen routing, table tools and native online ordering on paid plans. At $25,000 it costs about $42 a month more than Square Free. You give up flexibility: Toast Payments is required, hardware is Toast's own (a countertop terminal is about $800 to $1,200), and contracts typically run one to three years [4]. It fits a full-service room that wants one vendor. Read Toast against Square, Toast pricing and Toast alternatives.
SpotOn: hardware included, with a term
SpotOn lists All-In at $0 per station with hardware included and a two-year minimum, and POS Essentials at $55 a station, month to month [3]. All-In carries a higher card rate (2.79% + 20¢) in return for no upfront hardware bill. Essentials on one station costs about $17.50 more than Square Free at $25,000. You give up flexibility on All-In and pay for hardware on Essentials. Read SpotOn POS pricing.
Lightspeed: more tools, a higher bill
Lightspeed Restaurant is listed at $69, $189 and $399 a month per location, with a card rate of 2.6% + 10¢ [5]. It costs about $139 more than Square Free at $25,000 on Essential. What it buys is deeper inventory and multi-location tools. Read Lightspeed against Square and Lightspeed alternatives.
Revel: ask before you buy
Revel has never published one price. Older reviews give about $99 per terminal per month on a three-year contract with at least two terminals, and a newer listing says it is no longer sold as a standalone system since Shift4 bought it in 2024, which we could not confirm elsewhere [6]. Against Square Free it costs more at small and middle volume even before hardware. See Revel POS pricing and Revel against Square.
A free pickup page: no POS at all
Square's online rate is 3.3% + 30¢ on Free, about $1.29 on a $30 pickup order. A page with your menu and an order form, where diners pay at the counter, has no online card fee, no monthly fee and no contract. You give up the dining-room tools and the integrated terminal, so it fits as an addition to a cheap terminal, not as a replacement for a busy floor. Build one free, and read Square online ordering, commission-free online ordering and how to set up online ordering.
When Square is still the better buy
- Your card sales are under about $20,000 a month, where no monthly fee beats a lower percentage.
- You are opening and do not want a hardware bill yet: Square runs on a phone or tablet with a small reader.
- You want no long contract and a plan you can leave.
- Most of your sales are at a counter and you do not need coursing or a kitchen display.
How to choose among Square POS alternatives for restaurants
- Is the problem the price or a missing feature? If it is price, compare Clover's quote at your own volume; if it is a feature, name it before you look.
- Do you run a dining room with courses and a busy kitchen? Toast or Lightspeed's higher plans are built for it, at a higher monthly cost.
- Do you want no hardware bill at the start? SpotOn All-In or a lease, with the term and the higher rate that come with it.
- Do you mostly want pickup orders? A free pickup page beside a cheap terminal costs the least.
- Might you leave in a year? Prefer month-to-month terms and ask what hardware you keep.
Whichever of these Square POS alternatives for restaurants you pick, price it on your own month: card sales divided by the number of sales gives your average ticket, then multiply by each rate, add the fixed cents and the plan.
Questions to ask any rep
- Which plan is this quote, and what is its term and renewal?
- What are the exact in-person, online and keyed-in rates, and are they fixed?
- Is the hardware bought or leased, and can it run another processor?
- What are the setup, menu-entry and training fees?
- What does cancelling cost?
- Can I export my menu and sales history?
More pairings and prices: Square for Restaurants pricing, the best online ordering systems and all our guides.
Questions
What is the best alternative to Square for a restaurant?
Clover Starter costs less from about $25,000 a month in card sales; Toast fits a full-service room. Under about $10,000 a month, Square Free is the cheapest of them.
Is there a free alternative to Square POS?
SpotOn's All-In is $0 per station on a two-year term, and Toast has a $0 Starter Kit at higher card rates [3] [4]. Neither is cheaper than Square Free at small volume.
Which Square alternative has the lowest card rate?
Clover, reported at about 2.3% + 10¢ in person, against Square Free at 2.6% + 15¢ [1] [2]. Resellers can change it.
Can I keep my Square hardware if I switch?
Square's readers and terminals work with Square. Ask the new vendor whether any of it can be reused before you buy a second set.
Why would a restaurant leave Square?
Usually for restaurant-only tools such as coursing and kitchen routing, or a lower card rate at higher volume, not for the monthly fee.
Want pickup orders with no POS contract? Build your menu site free from a photo of your menu.
Sources
- Square for Restaurants pricing, our guide, citing UpMenu, GetApp, Capterra and FitSmallBusiness.
- Clover POS pricing, our guide, with its sources.
- SpotOn POS pricing, our guide, citing SpotOn's pricing page read Nov 16, 2026.
- Toast pricing, our guide, with its sources.
- Lightspeed Restaurant pricing, our guide, with its sources.
- Revel POS pricing, our guide, with its sources.
Prices change and resellers differ. Confirm with each vendor and read your own written quote.