Lightspeed vs Square for restaurants: plans, card rates, hardware and which costs less
Lightspeed vs Square for a restaurant is a choice between a $0 start and a paid system. Square's Free plan costs $0 a month with 2.6% + 15¢ on in-person cards, and its Plus ($49) and Premium ($149) plans lower the rate to 2.5% and 2.4% [1]. Lightspeed Restaurant lists $69 (Starter), $189 (Essential) and $399 (Premium) a month per location with 2.6% + 10¢ in person [1] [2]. On a $25,000 month at a $25 ticket, Square Free costs about $800 and Lightspeed Essential about $939. Square costs less for most small places; Lightspeed earns its fee only if you use what the higher plans add.
If you only need a menu page that takes pickup orders, you can build a free menu site with pickup ordering from a photo of your menu and skip both bills. Below: the plans side by side, a month worked out, the break-even, online orders, hardware, kitchen screens, and who each fits.
Lightspeed vs Square: plans and fees side by side
| Square for Restaurants | Lightspeed Restaurant | |
|---|---|---|
| Cheapest plan | Free, $0 a month [1] | Starter, about $69 a month [1] |
| Middle plan | Plus, $49 a month per location [1] | Essential, $189 a month per location [1] |
| Top plan | Premium, $149 a month per location, 24/7 phone support [1] | Premium, $399 a month; Enterprise custom [1] |
| In-person card rate | 2.6% + 15¢ (Free); 2.5% + 15¢ (Plus); 2.4% + 15¢ (Premium) [1] | 2.6% + 10¢ on Starter; custom on higher plans [1] |
| Online card rate | 3.3% + 30¢ (Free); 2.9% + 30¢ (Plus, Premium) [1] | 2.9% + 30¢ standard, negotiable [1] |
| Keyed card | 3.5% + 15¢ [1] | 3.5% + 30¢ [3] |
| Online ordering | Included on all plans, with a website builder and free subdomain [1] | From Essential in the sources we read [1] |
| Kitchen display | $30 a device a month (Plus), $20 (Premium) [1] | About $30 a screen a month [3] |
| Dispute fees | None [1] | $15 chargeback fee [1] |
| Contract | No multi-year term listed on the pages we read [1] | Software often month to month; payments agreement [3] |
Lightspeed's tiers are reported differently across sites: $69, $189 and $399 on one, $89, $149 and $289 on another (which may describe a different product) [1] [4]. Treat the numbers as a range and ask for a written quote that names the plan.
A month on each: three sizes
An illustration, not your numbers: one register, every sale a card swiped or tapped, an average ticket of $25 (400, 1,000 and 2,400 tickets). Hardware, kitchen screens and online orders are left out.
| Monthly card sales | Tickets | Square Free | Square Plus | Lightspeed Starter | Lightspeed Essential |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $10,000 | 400 | $320.00 | $359.00 | $369.00 | $489.00 |
| $25,000 | 1,000 | $800.00 | $824.00 | $819.00 | $939.00 |
| $60,000 | 2,400 | $1,920.00 | $1,909.00 | $1,869.00 | $1,989.00 |
The sums at $25,000: Square Free is 2.6% × $25,000 = $650 plus 1,000 × 15¢ = $150, total $800. Square Plus is $625 + $150 + $49 = $824. Lightspeed Starter is $650 + $100 + $69 = $819, and Essential $650 + $100 + $189 = $939. Square Premium at $60,000 would be $1,440 + $360 + $149 = $1,949.
Where each one wins
- Square Free against Lightspeed Starter. The percentage is the same (2.6%); Lightspeed's fixed fee is 5¢ lower, Starter costs $69. It needs $69 ÷ 5¢ = 1,380 tickets, about $34,500 a month at a $25 ticket, before Starter is cheaper. Below that, Square Free is.
- Square Free against Lightspeed Essential. $189 ÷ 5¢ = 3,780 tickets, about $94,500 a month. Almost no independent restaurant is there.
- Square Premium against Lightspeed Essential. Square charges 2.4% + 15¢, Lightspeed 2.6% + 10¢. At a $25 ticket that is 60¢ + 15¢ = 75¢ against 65¢ + 10¢ = 75¢: identical per ticket. Square Premium's plan is $40 cheaper, so it is cheaper at any ticket of $25 or more.
- Square Plus. It saves 0.1 point on every in-person card against Free, so it pays back its $49 above about $49,000 a month in card sales, and online its 0.4-point saving pays back above about $12,250 a month in online sales.
The pattern is the same in the three: the card rate, not the plan name, sets the bill, and Lightspeed's price needs volume or tools you will use.
Online ordering on Lightspeed vs Square
Square includes online selling on every plan, with a website builder and a free subdomain; a custom domain and more customisation come with Plus and Premium [1]. Lightspeed lists online ordering and contactless ordering from Essential [1]. Neither charges a commission. On a $25 online order, Square Free costs $1.13 (3.3% + 30¢), Square Plus or Premium and Lightspeed cost $1.03 (2.9% + 30¢). A $5 a month difference does not matter; a $75 monthly add-on would. For marketplaces, see DoorDash's commission, and for the setup of ordering from your own site see how to set up online ordering.
Hardware: Square against iPad systems
| Item | Square | Lightspeed |
|---|---|---|
| Reader | $59 (a magstripe reader may be free to new accounts) [1] | Smart terminal or reader about $399 [3] |
| Stand | $149 [1] | About $199 [3] |
| Terminal | $299 [1] | Runs on an iPad, about $349 [3] |
| Handheld | $399 [1] | iPad or reader |
| Register | $899 [1] | iPad plus stand |
| Kiosk | $149, plus app $50 a device a month on Plus or $30 on Premium [1] | Not priced in the sources we read |
Square sells its own hardware; Lightspeed runs on an iPad or desktop computer, and prices for printers, readers and accessories are not published [1]. If you already own an iPad, Lightspeed may save you on hardware; if you do not, a Square counter can start well under $500.
Features: what the extra money buys
Square Plus adds advanced POS, staff management, loyalty and email and text marketing; Premium adds business tools and phone support [1]. Square also lists a restaurant inventory add-on at $99 a location a month, and payroll at $35 a month plus $6 a person paid [1]. Lightspeed Essential adds online ordering, contactless ordering, tableside payments, multi-location management and advanced inventory; Premium adds multiple revenue centres and API access [1]. The right question is not which has more features but which ones you will use in the next year. If you will not use advanced inventory or several locations, the Lightspeed gap is a cost, not a benefit.
Costs that are easy to miss
Four lines tend to be left off a first quote. Kitchen screens: at $30 a screen a month on Square Plus or on Lightspeed, two screens add $60 a month, which is more than Square Plus itself. Setup and training: ask whether menu entry and staff training are charged; a one-time $500 to $1,000 changes a first-year comparison. Network gear: a router and a second printer for the kitchen are rarely in a hardware price. Currency: a Lightspeed price page can show Australian or Canadian dollars, so check that a US quote is in US dollars. Add each one to the month before you compare, and spread hardware over 36 months so it can be set against the monthly fee.
A quick test: write down last month's card sales and the number of sales, work out your average ticket, then price both systems with the sums above. If the answer is within $50 a month, choose on support, contract and the tools you will really use, not on the price table.
Contracts and switching
Neither source states a long term for Square, and Lightspeed's software is often month to month, but both involve a payments agreement [1] [3]. Ask before you sign: the term, the cancellation cost, whether the rate is fixed, whether hardware is locked to the processor, and whether you can export your menu and sales history. A system that is $60 cheaper a month but needs $800 of setup is only cheaper after 14 months.
Lightspeed vs Square: who each one fits
Square fits a café, a food truck, a counter-service or small takeout place, and a new restaurant that wants no monthly commitment. Lightspeed fits a full-service or multi-location restaurant that wants advanced inventory and reporting, and will pay for it. See the full-service side in Lightspeed against Toast and Lightspeed against Clover; alternatives are in Lightspeed alternatives for restaurants. Square on its own: Square for Restaurants pricing and Toast against Square. More: all our guides.
Questions
Is Square cheaper than Lightspeed for restaurants?
For most small restaurants, yes. At $25,000 of card sales on a $25 ticket, Square Free is about $800 against $939 on Lightspeed Essential.
Does Lightspeed have a free plan?
No free restaurant plan appears in the sources we read; its restaurant plans start around $69 a month [1].
Which has lower card rates?
Square Premium is 2.4% + 15¢ in person; Lightspeed Starter is 2.6% + 10¢. At a $25 ticket they cost the same per sale [1].
Does Square or Lightspeed charge for chargebacks?
Lightspeed lists a $15 chargeback fee; Square lists no chargeback or dispute fees [1].
Can I use my own iPad?
Lightspeed runs on an iPad or desktop computer; Square sells its own hardware [1].
Which is easier to switch away from?
Neither source lists a long term, but ask both for the cancellation terms and the hardware rules in writing.
Want pickup orders with no POS at all? Build your menu site free from a photo of your menu; diners pay you at the counter.
Sources
- Lightspeed vs. Square POS, business.com, updated Sept 17, 2026 (plans, rates, hardware, add-ons, chargebacks).
- Square for Restaurants pricing, our guide, with its sources.
- Toast vs. Lightspeed, UpMenu, updated May 12, 2026 (Lightspeed keyed rate, hardware, contracts; a rival vendor).
- Lightspeed Restaurant pricing, our guide, with its sources (conflicting tiers).
Prices change and resellers differ. Confirm with each vendor and read your own written quote.