Toast vs DoorDash for restaurants: what each costs on a $25 order and in a 300-order month
Toast and DoorDash do different jobs, so Toast vs DoorDash is not a like-for-like price check. Toast is the system you run the restaurant on, and its online ordering takes no commission: you pay a card fee reported at 3.5% + 15¢ on online orders and an add-on reported at about $75 a month [1]. DoorDash is an app that sends you diners and takes 15%, 25% or 30% of each delivered order and 6% of pickup [2]. On a $25 pickup order Toast costs about $1.03 and DoorDash $1.50. On a $25 delivered order Toast's own delivery costs more than DoorDash Basic, because it is a flat trip fee.
If you only want pickup orders from your own menu, you can build a menu site with pickup ordering from a photo of your menu, with no POS contract. Below: the two jobs, a side-by-side table, one $25 order six ways, a month of 300 orders, how many pickup orders pay for Toast's add-on, the order size where Toast delivery beats DoorDash, and who each one fits.
Toast vs DoorDash: they do different jobs
Toast is software and hardware. It runs your counter, your kitchen screens and your payments, and online ordering is an add-on to it. A guest orders from your Toast page, your Google listing or Toast's own app, and the order prints in your kitchen like any other [3][4]. The guest already knew about you. Toast does not send you strangers beyond what its guest app, Toast Local, brings by itself.
DoorDash is a marketplace. Diners open the app, browse, and pick you. The commission pays for being listed and found, for the Dasher who carries the food, for support and for card processing [2]. You pay only when an order arrives, and there is no monthly fee on these plans.
So the question is not which is cheaper. It is how many of your orders come from people who already know you, and how many from people who found you in the app. Orders from regulars are the ones you overpay for on DoorDash. Orders from strangers are the ones Toast cannot bring you. Our DoorDash alternatives guide compares the other ways to take orders at no commission.
Side by side
| Toast online ordering | DoorDash Marketplace | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Your ordering page, part of the Toast POS | A diner app that lists you |
| Who finds you | Your own guests; some from Toast Local [4] | Anyone in the app |
| Commission, pickup | None | 6% on every US plan [2] |
| Commission, delivery | None; a flat trip fee if Toast sends the driver [3] | 15% / 25% / 30% by plan [2] |
| Card fee, online | 3.5% + 15¢ reported, hardware bought upfront [1] | Covered by the commission [2] |
| Monthly fee | Add-on reported at about $75; quote-based [1][5] | None |
| You also need | The Toast POS ($0 Starter Kit or about $69 a terminal reported; two to three year contract) [1] | A tablet or the Merchant Portal |
| Delivery drivers | Uber Direct or DoorDash Drive, a flat fee per trip [3] | DoorDash Dashers |
The Toast figures are reports, not Toast's own price list: Toast does not publish a price for online ordering. Read them as a map and ask for a written quote. Our Toast online ordering and DoorDash commission guides carry every source.
One $25 order, six ways
One $25 food subtotal, before food cost and tax. Toast's card fee on the order is 3.5% of $25 plus 15¢, which is $1.03. Toast delivery adds the $7.49 DoorDash Drive trip fee for a delivery within 5 miles [3]; tip and any Toast service fee are left out.
| How the order comes in | Fee | You keep of $25 |
|---|---|---|
| Toast page, pickup, paid by card online | $1.03 | $23.97 |
| DoorDash app, pickup | 6% = $1.50 | $23.50 |
| DoorDash Basic, delivered | 15% = $3.75 | $21.25 |
| DoorDash Plus, delivered | 25% = $6.25 | $18.75 |
| DoorDash Premier, delivered | 30% = $7.50 | $17.50 |
| Toast page, delivered by DoorDash Drive | $1.03 + $7.49 = $8.52 | $16.48, before any delivery charge the diner pays |
Two things stand out. Pickup is cheaper on Toast, but only by 47¢. And on a $25 delivery, Toast's flat trip fee costs more than any DoorDash plan. The diner's delivery charge changes this: Toast turns on a $3.99 delivery charge by default, set by your restaurant, which comes back to you [3]. On DoorDash the diner's delivery and service fees go to DoorDash, not to you [2].
A month at 300 orders
An example, not your numbers: 300 orders a month at $25, which is $7,500 in sales, all on one channel. Toast includes the add-on at $75.
| Channel | How it is worked out | Month |
|---|---|---|
| Toast, all pickup | 3.5% of $7,500 = $262.50; 300 × 15¢ = $45; add-on $75 | $382.50 |
| DoorDash, all pickup | 6% of $7,500 | $450.00 |
| DoorDash Basic, all delivered | 15% of $7,500 | $1,125 |
| DoorDash Plus, all delivered | 25% of $7,500 | $1,875 |
| DoorDash Premier, all delivered | 30% of $7,500 | $2,250 |
| Toast, all delivered by DoorDash Drive | $307.50 card fees + 300 × $7.49 ($2,247) + $75 add-on | $2,629.50 |
The last row is the one to notice. If Toast sends every order out with a driver, it costs more a month than DoorDash Premier on orders of this size, before the diner's delivery charge. That is not a reason to avoid Toast delivery. It is a reason to look at your average order before you turn it on. A catering-size order is a different story, below.
Pickup: how many orders pay for Toast's add-on
If you already run Toast, the add-on is the fixed cost. Each pickup order that moves from the DoorDash app to your Toast page saves the difference between DoorDash's 6% and Toast's card fee. At a $75 add-on:
| Order size | DoorDash pickup, 6% | Toast online card fee | Saved per order | Orders to cover $75 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $25 | $1.50 | $1.03 | $0.48 | 158 |
| $40 | $2.40 | $1.55 | $0.85 | 89 |
| $60 | $3.60 | $2.25 | $1.35 | 56 |
Pickup alone is a thin saving. At a $25 average you would need to move about 158 pickup orders a month just to cover the add-on. The bigger gain is delivery regulars who start ordering from your own link, and who would otherwise cost you 25% to 30%. For them the saving is the commission minus the card fee, minus a driver if you send one. Our guide to DoorDash commission on pickup orders shows why a 6% rate is low enough that pickup alone rarely justifies a monthly plan.
Delivery: the order size where Toast beats DoorDash
Toast's delivery cost per order is the card fee plus a flat trip fee: 3.5% + 15¢ + $7.49, or about 3.5% of the order plus $7.64. DoorDash's is a share of the order. A flat fee wins on big orders and loses on small ones. Per order:
| Order size | Toast + DoorDash Drive | DoorDash Basic 15% | DoorDash Plus 25% | DoorDash Premier 30% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $20 | $8.34 | $3.00 | $5.00 | $6.00 |
| $30 | $8.69 | $4.50 | $7.50 | $9.00 |
| $40 | $9.04 | $6.00 | $10.00 | $12.00 |
| $60 | $9.74 | $9.00 | $15.00 | $18.00 |
| $80 | $10.44 | $12.00 | $20.00 | $24.00 |
Break-even: Toast delivery costs less than DoorDash Premier above about $29 an order, less than Plus above about $36, and less than Basic only above about $66. Those figures leave out the diner's delivery charge (yours on Toast, DoorDash's on the app), the driver's tip, Toast's service fee and the mileage add-on past 5 miles. They also leave out the main thing the commission buys: a stranger found you. A catering or family order is where a flat fee starts to make sense. A $20 lunch is not.
What Toast cannot do: bring you strangers
Toast Local, Toast's own guest app, lists restaurants that use Toast. It costs nothing extra, takes no commission, and Toast says it has no plans to charge one [4]. It is small next to a marketplace with DoorDash's reach, and guests there are in the US only. If a large share of your orders come from people who never heard of you, dropping DoorDash for Toast alone will cut your orders. Start by measuring: for a month, count orders by source. Our online ordering on Google guide shows how to put an Order button on your listing so more regulars use your own link.
Can you use Toast and DoorDash together?
Many restaurants do. Toast runs the counter and takes direct orders; DoorDash lists the restaurant for discovery on the lowest plan that still gets it listed. What we could not confirm from the sources we read is whether DoorDash Marketplace orders print on your Toast screens without a tablet. Ask both companies in writing before you plan around it. A separate tablet on the counter is common, and it is a cost in staff attention, not a fee.
- Keep DoorDash on Basic at 15% if you need it for discovery.
- Put your Toast ordering link on your Google profile, your website and a counter sign.
- After 60 days, count orders by source and fill the tables above with your own numbers.
- If the add-on is not covered by moved orders, ask Toast what dropping it costs, or test a free page.
Which one fits
- Toast fits a restaurant that already runs Toast, has regulars, wants to keep their emails and orders, and sells pickup or large delivery orders.
- DoorDash fits a restaurant that needs to be found, has a delivery-friendly menu, and can price the commission into it, ideally on Basic.
- Neither fits a place that only wants a menu page and pickup orders. That is a smaller tool, and a free one works.
Mistakes when comparing them
- Comparing a POS with an app. Toast needs a two to three year POS contract [1]; DoorDash needs none. If you are not on Toast yet, the POS decision is bigger than the ordering one.
- Using 3.5% + 15¢ as a quote. Card rates are negotiated per account. Read the rate on your own statement.
- Ignoring order size. The break-even above moves from $29 to $66 depending on the plan.
- Dropping DoorDash on day one. Run both for 60 days before you cut either.
Frequently asked questions
Is Toast cheaper than DoorDash?
Per pickup order, yes: $1.03 against $1.50 on $25. Per delivered order under about $29 to $66, no: Toast's flat trip fee is higher than DoorDash's commission on a small order. Toast also has a monthly add-on and needs its POS.
Does Toast charge commission on online orders?
No. Toast keeps the card fee on each online order, and Toast says it has no plans to charge a commission on Toast Local [4].
Does DoorDash charge commission on pickup?
Yes, 6% on every US plan [2].
Does Toast have its own delivery drivers?
No. Toast Delivery Services sends orders to Uber Direct or DoorDash Drive drivers for a flat fee per trip, from $6.99 to $9.99 on Uber Direct and from $7.49 on DoorDash Drive [3].
Can I use my Toast page to take DoorDash-style orders?
You can take orders from your own guests, with pickup or delivery. DoorDash's own online ordering for your website is a separate DoorDash product, at 0% commission and card processing of 2.9% + 30¢ [2].
What if I only want pickup?
A page with pickup ordering and no monthly plan costs less than either. You can build yours from a photo of your menu; more answers are in all our guides.
Sources
- Toast POS review, NerdWallet, updated Aug 6, 2026, read Nov 4, 2026 (card rates, quote-based online ordering, contract length).
- Our DoorDash commission fee guide: DoorDash pricing, read Nov 1, 2026 (15%, 25%, 30%; 6% pickup; 2.9% + 30¢ on own-website orders).
- Toast Delivery Services, Toast support, updated Oct 26, 2026, read Nov 4, 2026 (trip fees, default $3.99 delivery charge).
- Toast Local FAQ, Toast support, read Nov 4, 2026.
- Toast online ordering pricing and fees, Sauce, read Nov 4, 2026 (a rival; add-on about $75 a month as reported).
Prices change and most comparison pages are written by a rival. Confirm with each company in writing.