Toast vs Grubhub for restaurants: what each costs on a $25 order, a month of pickup and a delivery
Toast vs Grubhub is a system you run your restaurant on against an app that sends you diners. Toast's online ordering takes no commission: you pay a card fee reported at 3.5% + 15¢ on online orders and an add-on reported at about $75 a month [1]. Grubhub charges a marketing commission of 5%, 15% or 20% by plan, a delivery fee from 10% when its drivers deliver, and card processing of 3.05% + 30¢ [2]. On a $25 pickup order Toast costs about $1.03; Grubhub costs $2.31 on Basic and up to $6.06 on All-access.
If you only want pickup orders from your own menu, you can build a menu site with pickup ordering from a photo of your menu, with no POS contract. Below: the two jobs, a side-by-side table, one $25 order seven ways, a month of 300 orders, how many pickups pay for the Toast add-on, the order size where Toast delivery beats Grubhub, and who each one fits.
Toast vs Grubhub: different jobs
Toast is software and hardware: it runs your counter, kitchen screens and payments, and online ordering is an add-on that puts your menu on a page, in Toast's guest app and behind the Order button on your Google listing [3]. The people ordering already know you, or found you in Toast Local.
Grubhub is a marketplace. Diners browse and pick you, and you pay a commission on each order the app sends. The commission pays for being listed and found; on top of it, a Grubhub driver costs a delivery fee [2].
So a price check is not enough. A restaurant that is already on Toast asks whether the add-on is cheaper than the commission on orders it could take itself. A restaurant that is not on Toast is looking at a two to three year POS contract [1], which is a far bigger decision than ordering. Our Toast online ordering and Grubhub commission guides carry every source.
Side by side
| Toast online ordering | Grubhub Marketplace | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Your ordering page, part of the Toast POS | A diner app that lists you |
| Marketing commission | None | 5% / 15% / 20% by plan [2] |
| Delivery | Uber Direct or DoorDash Drive, flat fee a trip [3] | Grubhub drivers, fee from 10% [2] |
| Card fee, online | 3.5% + 15¢ reported [1] | 3.05% + 30¢ on prepaid orders [4] |
| Monthly fee | Add-on reported at about $75 [1][5] | None to be listed [2] |
| Own-site ordering | The main product | Grubhub Direct, commission-free [2] |
| You also need | The Toast POS; contract two to three years [1] | Nothing, apart from a tablet or portal |
The Toast figures are reports, not Toast's own price list; Toast does not publish a price for online ordering. Get a written quote before you rely on them.
One $25 order, seven ways
One $25 food subtotal, before food cost and tax. Toast's fee: 3.5% + 15¢ = $1.03. Grubhub's processing: 3.05% + 30¢ = $1.06 on top of the commission. Toast delivery adds the DoorDash Drive trip fee for a delivery within 5 miles, $7.49 [3]; tip and any service fee are left out.
| How the order comes in | Fees | You keep of $25 |
|---|---|---|
| Toast page, pickup, paid by card online | $1.03 | $23.97 |
| Grubhub Basic, pickup | $1.25 + $1.06 = $2.31 | $22.69 |
| Grubhub Plus, pickup | $3.75 + $1.06 = $4.81 | $20.19 |
| Grubhub All-access, pickup | $5.00 + $1.06 = $6.06 | $18.94 |
| Grubhub Basic, delivered by Grubhub | $3.75 + $1.06 = $4.81 | $20.19 |
| Grubhub Plus, delivered by Grubhub | $6.25 + $1.06 = $7.31 | $17.69 |
| Toast page, delivered by DoorDash Drive | $1.03 + $7.49 = $8.52 | $16.48, before any delivery charge the diner pays |
Grubhub's pricing page lists no separate pickup rate, and the guides that work through its calculator treat a pickup order as the plan's marketing rate plus processing [2][4]. If you are on Plus or All-access, a pickup can cost you three times what DoorDash charges for the same order. On delivery, a $25 order costs about the same on Toast as on Grubhub's top plan.
A month at 300 orders
An example, not your numbers: 300 orders at $25, which is $7,500. Toast: 3.5% is $262.50, plus 300 × 15¢ is $45, plus the add-on $75. Grubhub processing is 3.05% of $7,500 plus 300 × 30¢, $318.75.
| Channel | How it is worked out | Month |
|---|---|---|
| Toast, all pickup | $262.50 + $45 + $75 | $382.50 |
| Grubhub Basic, all pickup | 5% of $7,500 = $375 + $318.75 | $693.75 |
| Grubhub Plus, all pickup | 15% = $1,125 + $318.75 | $1,443.75 |
| Grubhub All-access, all pickup | 20% = $1,500 + $318.75 | $1,818.75 |
| Grubhub Basic, all delivered by Grubhub | 15% = $1,125 + $318.75 | $1,443.75 |
| Grubhub Plus, all delivered by Grubhub | 25% = $1,875 + $318.75 | $2,193.75 |
| Toast, all delivered by DoorDash Drive | $307.50 + 300 × $7.49 ($2,247) + $75 | $2,629.50 |
Pickup is where Toast is far cheaper. Delivery is where it is not, at this order size: a $25 order with a flat $7.49 trip is not cheap. That is a reason to look at your average order before you turn on Toast delivery, not a reason to skip it.
Pickup: how many orders pay for the Toast add-on
If you already run Toast, the add-on is a fixed cost. Each pickup order you move from Grubhub to your own page saves the Grubhub pickup fee and costs the Toast card fee. At $75 for the add-on, at a $25 order:
| Your Grubhub plan | Grubhub pickup fee | Toast card fee | Saved per order | Orders to cover $75 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Basic 5% | $2.31 | $1.03 | $1.29 | 59 |
| Plus 15% | $4.81 | $1.03 | $3.79 | 20 |
| All-access 20% | $6.06 | $1.03 | $5.04 | 15 |
On Grubhub Plus, 20 regulars a month who start using your own link pay for the add-on. That is a low bar. On Basic it takes 59, still small next to a 300-order month. The orders have to be real regulars who would have ordered anyway, not new diners the app found. Our online ordering on Google guide shows how to put the link where regulars look.
Delivery: the order size where Toast beats Grubhub
Toast delivery costs 3.5% of the order plus about $7.64 (the $7.49 trip and the 15¢). Grubhub delivered costs the plan's marketing rate plus 10% for its driver plus 3.05% + 30¢. At the 10% floor, that is 18.05% of the order plus 30¢ on Basic, 28.05% plus 30¢ on Plus and 33.05% plus 30¢ on All-access. Per order:
| Order size | Toast + DoorDash Drive | Grubhub Basic delivered | Grubhub Plus delivered | Grubhub All-access delivered |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $20 | $8.34 | $3.91 | $5.91 | $6.91 |
| $30 | $8.69 | $5.72 | $8.72 | $10.22 |
| $40 | $9.04 | $7.52 | $11.52 | $13.52 |
| $60 | $9.74 | $11.13 | $17.13 | $20.13 |
The break-evens: Toast delivery costs less than All-access above about $25 an order, less than Plus above about $30, and less than Basic above about $50. Grubhub says its delivery fee starts at 10%, so the real fee may be higher and the break-evens lower. Left out: the diner's delivery charge (yours on Toast, set by you), the driver's tip, Toast's service fee and the mileage add-on past 5 miles. Left out too, and not small: Grubhub's commission buys a diner who found you in an app.
Can you use Toast and Grubhub together?
Many restaurants do: Toast for the counter and direct orders, and a marketplace listing for discovery. We could not confirm from the sources we read whether Grubhub orders print on Toast screens without a tablet, so ask both in writing. A simple way to start:
- Move to the lowest Grubhub plan that keeps you listed.
- Put your Toast ordering link on your Google profile, website and counter sign.
- After 60 days, count orders by source and fill the tables above with your numbers.
- Keep the add-on if moved orders cover it. If they do not, ask Toast what dropping it costs.
Which one fits
- Toast fits a restaurant that already runs Toast, has regulars, and sells pickup or large delivery orders.
- Grubhub fits a restaurant that needs to be found in an app, delivers a lot, and can price the commission into its menu. Basic is the plan most worth checking.
- Neither fits a restaurant that only wants a menu page and pickup. A free page does that. Our DoorDash vs Uber Eats vs Grubhub guide compares the three apps instead.
Mistakes when comparing them
- Comparing a POS with an app. Toast needs a two to three year contract [1]; Grubhub needs none.
- Taking 3.5% + 15¢ as a quote. Card rates are negotiated per account; read your statement.
- Using Grubhub's 5% as the price. It is a listing rate. With a Grubhub driver it is at least 15% before processing.
- Counting every Grubhub order as keepable. Some exist only because the app showed you.
Frequently asked questions
Is Toast cheaper than Grubhub?
Per pickup order, yes: about $1.03 against $2.31 to $6.06 on $25. Per delivered order under about $25 to $50, no. Toast also has a monthly add-on and needs its POS.
Does Toast charge commission on online orders?
No. Toast keeps the card fee on each online order [1][3].
How much does Grubhub charge restaurants?
5%, 15% or 20% marketing commission, a delivery fee from 10% with Grubhub drivers, and 3.05% + 30¢ processing [2][4]. See Grubhub commission fee for restaurants.
Does Toast have its own delivery drivers?
No. Toast Delivery Services uses Uber Direct or DoorDash Drive for a flat fee per trip [3]. Compare Toast vs DoorDash.
Can I switch from Grubhub to Toast online ordering?
You can add Toast ordering and keep Grubhub. Run both for 60 days before you cut either.
What if I only want pickup?
A page with pickup ordering and no monthly plan is cheaper than either. You can build yours from a photo of your menu; more answers are in all our guides.
Sources
- Toast POS review, NerdWallet, updated Aug 6, 2026, read Nov 4, 2026 (card rates, quote-based online ordering, contract length).
- Pricing and fees, Grubhub for Restaurants, read Nov 3, 2026, with Menuline on its calculator (5/15/20%, delivery from 10%); Direct is described on Grubhub for Restaurants.
- Toast Delivery Services, Toast support, updated Oct 26, 2026, read Nov 4, 2026 (trip fees).
- How much does Grubhub charge restaurants?, Restolabs, updated July 27, 2026, read Nov 3, 2026 (3.05% + $0.30).
- Toast online ordering pricing and fees, Sauce, read Nov 4, 2026 (a rival; add-on about $75 a month as reported).
Prices change and most comparison pages are written by a rival. Confirm with each company in writing.