GatherUp vs NiceJob: Price, Features and Which Fits
GatherUp vs NiceJob is a choice between a $99 feedback and review toolkit and a $75 review sender. GatherUp's own page lists $99 a month for one location on yearly billing. NiceJob is reported at about $75 a month, month to month. This guide is for a local business owner who wants more Google reviews and has narrowed the list to these two.
First, check your Google reviews against your nearest rivals for free. You get your review link, a printable QR sign and written replies, so you know what a tool would add.
GatherUp vs NiceJob at a glance
| Question | GatherUp | NiceJob |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Feedback, review requests, replies, monitoring, surveys | Review requests and follow-ups after a job |
| One location, price | $99 a month, billed annually (vendor page, 2026-11-13) | About $75 a month (Reviews), about $125 (Pro), reported |
| Several locations | $60 a month per location, billed annually | Price steps up with customers served a year |
| Trial | 14 days, no card | 14 days, no card, reported |
| Contract | Month to month, or annual at about 20% less | Month to month reported |
| Rating we saw | 4.6 of 5 from 41 on Capterra; 4.5 from 49 on G2 | About 4.8 from 419 on G2; 4.8 to 4.9 on Capterra |
| Texts and emails | Up to 300 texts and 3,000 emails per location a month | Text and email invites, limits not found |
| Extras | AI-drafted replies, surveys, 100+ site monitoring, widgets, API | Social sharing, website widget on some plans, CRM links |
The short answer: NiceJob costs less and does one job. GatherUp costs more and gives you surveys, monitoring and reply drafts in the same plan. Pick by the features you will really use.
What does GatherUp do?
GatherUp asks customers for feedback and reviews, then collects and shows them. A customer gets a text or email and rates you. It drafts replies you can post from the app, watches review sites, runs surveys with a Net Promoter Score (the "would you recommend us" number) and makes a widget you can put on your site. It also sells Listings Management and Review Defense as separate products. See GatherUp reviews and GatherUp pricing.
What does NiceJob do?
NiceJob sends a review request after a job, by text or email, with a link to your Google review box. If the customer does not answer, it follows up. It can share reviews on social media and, on some plans, show them on your site. It links to job software so a finished job triggers the ask. It is not a rank tracker or a listings tool. See NiceJob reviews and NiceJob pricing.
GatherUp vs NiceJob pricing for one location
| Item | GatherUp | NiceJob Reviews |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly | $99 (annual billing) | about $75 |
| One year | $1,188 | $900 |
| Gap | $288 a year more for GatherUp | |
| Customers to break even at $200 profit each | about 6 | 4.5 |
The $200 is an example. Use your own profit per new customer. The gap is small, so features and terms should decide this, not price alone.
Watch the extras. GatherUp splits its price into products. Listings Management is $40 a month per location and Review Defense starts at $45 a month per location on an annual commitment. A one-location owner who adds Listings would pay $99 plus $40, which is $139 a month. NiceJob's Pro plan is reported at about $125 and its website bundle from about $174. Ask each for a written quote with every line.
GatherUp vs NiceJob for several locations
GatherUp lists $60 a month per location for two or more locations on annual billing. Three locations would be $180 a month, or $2,160 a year. NiceJob's price is reported to rise with the number of customers you serve a year. One listing says the plans cover up to 2,500 customers a year and then step up. We could not confirm each step, so ask NiceJob which tier your count falls in, and what the next one costs.
A busy business with many customers but one location, such as a car wash, may find GatherUp's per-location price steadier. A business with a few hundred customers a year will not feel NiceJob's steps at all.
Which one has the better reviews?
NiceJob scores higher, about 4.8 out of 5 from 419 reviews on G2 against 4.5 from 49 for GatherUp (seen 2026-11-20). That is a big gap in crowd size too. Forty-nine reviews can be moved by a few happy users, so do not treat 4.8 against 4.6 as a clear win. What repeats matters more:
- GatherUp praise: easy to use, one dashboard for many sites, the website widget, support. Complaints: no Yelp link, no saved email templates, a delay before reviews show, a price that was hard to find.
- NiceJob praise: easy to use, automatic reminders, helpful support, CRM link. Complaints: narrow focus, duplicate entries from 3 reviews, price for some.
Neither list shows a pattern of surprise charges. That is a good sign next to tools such as Podium, where cancel stories are a pattern.
Contracts: the one trap to know
GatherUp's page says Reputation Management can be month to month, annual paid upfront at a discount, or annual paid in monthly installments. Annual plans need a full year whatever the payment method. The installment option looks like a monthly plan but is a 12-month promise. Before you click, ask yourself: month to month, or a year with monthly payments?
The page does not show the month-to-month price in the text we read, so ask for it. Review Defense is annual only. On annual plans you can add locations during the term but not remove them until it ends.
NiceJob is reported month to month with no long contract. That makes a test cheap: one month at most. Confirm on the sign-up page.
Review gating: ask before you buy
Some tools ask customers to rate you first and then send only the happy ones to Google. That is review gating, and Google says not to do it. Ask each company how its flow works. Your request should go to every customer. Our guide on how to ask customers for a Google review has the words to use.
How to read GatherUp and NiceJob reviews
A star score is a start, not an answer. Use this short checklist on both tools.
- Check the plan. A review of an agency or multi-location plan may praise things a one-shop plan does not have.
- Check the date. Plan names and prices change. A review from two years ago may describe a plan that no longer exists.
- Read the 2 and 3 star reviews first. That is where owners write what they did not like.
- Look for the job. A roofer and a restaurant want different things from the same tool.
- Look for money words. Cancel, renew, charge and refund tell you more than "great tool".
Also note that some summaries on review sites are written by a machine, so lean on the real quotes and the counts.
Who should pick GatherUp?
- You want surveys and a Net Promoter Score along with reviews.
- You manage several locations and the $60 per location rate fits.
- You want AI-drafted replies and monitoring of 100+ review sites in the plan.
- You will pay annually and have read the terms.
Who should pick NiceJob?
- You run a home service or similar business and want the simplest review sender.
- You want month to month terms and a cheaper first month.
- Your jobs are logged in software that NiceJob links to.
- You do not need surveys or monitoring.
What if neither fits?
See GatherUp alternatives and NiceJob alternatives. For a bigger tool, read NiceJob vs Podium and Birdeye vs NiceJob. For a related plan from the same family, Grade.us reviews covers the agency-leaning tool tied to GatherUp.
The free way to do the same job
- Make your Google review link.
- Use a short text from our review text message template.
- Send it the day the job ends to every customer.
- Send one reminder three days later to those who did not answer.
- Reply to every review. See Google review response templates.
Both GatherUp and NiceJob only automate this. At five jobs a week you can do it by hand in ten minutes a day.
A test plan for the 14-day trial
- Day 0: write down your review count and your three nearest rivals' counts.
- Day 1: load a real customer list and send to a phone you control.
- Day 7: count requests sent, clicks and reviews that show on Google.
- Day 12: decide. If the cost per new review is above what plain texting costs you in time, skip it.
Frequently asked questions
Is GatherUp better than NiceJob?
Not in general. GatherUp has more features, such as surveys and monitoring, and costs more. NiceJob is simpler and is reported cheaper. Choose by what you will use.
How much is GatherUp compared with NiceJob?
GatherUp lists $99 a month for one location billed annually. NiceJob is reported at about $75 a month for Reviews and about $125 for Pro.
Do both have a free trial?
Yes, GatherUp lists 14 days with no card. NiceJob is reported to offer 14 days without a card. Check each sign-up page.
Which is better for several locations?
GatherUp lists a $60 per location rate for two or more locations. NiceJob's price steps with customers served. Get both quoted in writing for your count.
Can I get reviews without either?
Yes. A review link, a text and a QR sign are enough for a small shop.
What to do next
Start with the free check of your Google reviews. More plain guides are on the guides page.
Sources
- GatherUp pricing page, read 2026-11-13 (via our GatherUp pricing guide).
- Capterra, Software Advice and G2 listings for GatherUp and NiceJob, seen 2026-11-20.
- NiceJob pricing reports from Capterra, Software Advice and comparison pages, read 2026-11-13.